All articles

Dirac concentration and discrete Wasserstein flows

When does an attractive interaction concentrate all the mass at a single vertex? The decisive role of mobilities that vanish at the boundary of the simplex.

Abstract

We study attractive interaction flows on a finite discrete torus equipped with the Wasserstein–Maas geometry. The logarithmic mobility vanishes when an endpoint of an edge has zero mass, so the order in which sites become empty is essential to concentration. We work with the continuous extension of the coordinate vector field to the closed probability simplex and do not assume uniqueness of boundary continuations.

Our first result characterizes the initial data from which every global solution converges to a prescribed Dirac mass. The criterion is a countable family of rational polynomial inequalities, obtained from an alternative between confinement and escape for continuous vector fields. For \(d\geq2\) and the reduced interaction governed by the first Fourier modes, a more explicit classification is available for initial masses of order \(\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}\) on successive graph-distance shells. When consecutive exponent gaps are unequal, their strict increase is equivalent to convergence of the support-nonincreasing continuation and to convergence of every global solution. In this case concentration occurs in finite time, of order at most \(\varepsilon^{\alpha_1}|\log\varepsilon|\).

In the same dimensions, two affine mass inequalities define nonempty open sets, arbitrarily close to each Dirac mass, on which the polynomial certificates are impossible. The same inequalities keep every global solution a positive distance from all Dirac masses. This obstruction is uniform for the reduced flow and for all positive parameters in the exponential interaction; the multiscale classification also extends to the latter, uniformly on bounded positive parameter intervals after time rescaling. Thus proximity to a Dirac mass does not determine the outcome: the distribution of exterior mass across transporting shells is decisive.

1. Introduction

An attractive interaction energy favors probability measures supported at a single site. Whether its gradient dynamics actually reach such a measure depends on the transport geometry as well as on the energy. On a finite graph with logarithmic mobility, these two ingredients interact particularly strongly at the boundary of the probability simplex: a vanishing coordinate removes the mobility of every incident edge. A small amount of mass away from a prospective concentration site can therefore have different long-time outcomes according to the intermediate sites through which it must pass.

This paper studies that boundary mechanism on a discrete torus. We seek conditions on the initial probability measure that determine convergence to a Dirac mass, and we distinguish a global theoretical characterization from a directly usable criterion for a class of multiscale data. The analysis also identifies an open obstruction to concentration near every Dirac mass. The resulting coexistence of concentration and non-concentration is a feature of the boundary-extended Wasserstein equation itself.

Background and motivation

The variational formulation of diffusion in the space of probability measures originates, in particular, in the work of Jordan, Kinderlehrer, and Otto on the Fokker–Planck equation [7]. Otto’s Riemannian interpretation of the porous medium equation [12] explains how a transport metric converts the differential of an energy into an evolution equation. These works provide a natural starting point for asking analogous questions on finite state spaces, where the choice of mobility must be specified explicitly.

Maas [10] constructed a transport distance for finite reversible Markov chains whose entropy gradient flow is the heat equation. The logarithmic mean is central to that correspondence. Related gradient structures were developed by Mielke [11] and by Chow, Huang, Li, and Zhou [1]. Erbar and Maas [3] extended the transport-gradient viewpoint to discrete porous medium equations with suitable mobilities. Weighted graph Laplacians also underlie the Riemannian calculus on the probability simplex developed by Li [9], with a different choice of mobility. Throughout the present paper, mass is carried by vertices and exchanged across edges. This finite-state geometry is distinct from transport on a metric graph, where mass can be distributed along the edges themselves; see Erbar, Forkert, Maas, and Mugnolo [2] for the latter setting.

A further motivation comes from concentration in self-attention dynamics. Geshkovski, Letrouit, Polyanskiy, and Rigollet [5] study mathematical models of Transformers through interacting systems and transport equations. Geshkovski, Koubbi, Polyanskiy, and Rigollet [4] establish dynamic metastability for a self-attention model on the sphere, with long-lived multiple clusters preceding collapse. Exponential functions of a similarity kernel are natural in that context. Here the sites remain fixed, the unknowns are their probability masses, and transport is restricted to nearest-neighbor edges. The question becomes how this transport constraint and its degenerating mobility change the concentration mechanism. In particular, an empty intermediate shell can separate surviving mass from the central site.

The global characterization below uses a second line of ideas: occupation measures and their dual inequalities. Such formulations are developed for nonlinear optimal control by Lasserre, Henrion, Prieur, and Trélat [8], and for regions of attraction of polynomial control systems by Henrion and Korda [6]. Our vector field contains the logarithmic mean and is only continuous on the closed simplex. We therefore prove the confinement–escape alternative needed here directly, without assuming polynomial dynamics or uniqueness of trajectories. The resulting polynomial tests give an exact criterion; no finite-degree decision procedure is asserted.

Model and notation

Fix integers \(N\geq3\) and \(d\geq1\). The state space is \[X=(\mathbb Z/N\mathbb Z)^d, \qquad x\sim y\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad y=x\pm e_j\ \text{for some }1\leq j\leq d,\] where \(e_j\) is the \(j\)th coordinate vector and addition is modulo \(N\). The symmetric edge weights are \[a(x,y)=\frac1{2d}\mathbf1_{\{x\sim y\}}.\] We use probability masses, normalized with respect to counting measure: \[\tag{1.1} \mathcal P(X)=\left\{\rho\in[0,\infty)^X:\sum_x\rho(x)=1\right\}, \qquad \mathcal P_*(X)=\{\rho\in\mathcal P(X):\rho(x)>0\ \forall x\}.\] The unit mass at \(\xi\) is denoted by \(\delta_\xi\). The topology of the simplex is its Euclidean topology, equivalently that induced by \(\|\rho\|_{\ell^1(X)}=\sum_x|\rho(x)|\). The support is \(\operatorname{supp}\rho=\{x:\rho(x)>0\}\).

For vertex functions, convolution, the Euclidean pairing, and the Fourier transform are normalized by \[\begin{aligned} (f*g)(x)&=\sum_{y\in X}f(x-y)g(y), &\langle f,g\rangle_{\rm euc}&=\sum_{x\in X}f(x)g(x),\\ \widehat f(m)&=\sum_{x\in X}f(x)e^{-2\pi i\langle m,x\rangle/N}, &A_j(\rho)&=\widehat\rho(e_j). \end{aligned}\] The interaction kernels are \[\tag{1.2} \sigma(z)=\sum_{j=1}^d\cos\left(\frac{2\pi z_j}{N}\right), \qquad k_\beta(z)=e^{\beta\sigma(z)},\qquad \beta>0.\] Both are even. Their associated quadratic energies are \[\tag{1.3} E_h(\rho)=\langle\rho,h*\rho\rangle_{\rm euc}, \qquad J=E_\sigma,\qquad E_\beta=E_{k_\beta}.\] The symbol \(h\) will always mean either \(\sigma\) or one fixed \(k_\beta\). The term full unperturbed flow refers to \(k_\beta\); the reduced flow refers to \(\sigma\). The latter is the leading-order equation after rescaling time by \(\beta\), as established in Section 2.

Main results and organization

The argument proceeds from geometry to a general criterion, then to explicit concentration and obstruction mechanisms. All assertions at the boundary concern the continuous extension of the coordinate equation. Section 2 constructs forward-complete solutions and singles out the unique continuation with nonincreasing support. It then establishes monotonicity of each first Fourier mode for the reduced flow. These preliminary facts explain why boundary continuations and more than total energy must enter the concentration analysis.

A global theoretical characterization.

Theorem 3.4 characterizes the initial data from which every global solution converges to a prescribed \(\delta_\xi\). For a fixed sequence of compact sets exhausting the complement of \(\delta_\xi\), the condition is the existence of rational polynomials that are negative at the initial datum and satisfy a strict discounted Lie-derivative inequality on each compact set. All quantities in the criterion are evaluated on the state space. Its proof rests on the occupation-measure alternative in Proposition 3.2 and the polynomial escape theorem, Theorem 3.3. The universal quantifier is essential because boundary uniqueness is not assumed.

An explicit multiscale classification.

For \(d\geq2\) and the reduced equation, Theorem 4.2 considers initial masses comparable, site by site, to \(\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}\) on the shell at graph distance \(m\) from \(\xi\). With \(0=\alpha_0<\alpha_1<\cdots<\alpha_R\), and excluding equal consecutive gaps, the criterion is strict discrete convexity: \[\alpha_{m+1}-\alpha_m>\alpha_m-\alpha_{m-1} \qquad(1\leq m<R).\] This is equivalent both to convergence of the support-nonincreasing continuation and to convergence of every global solution. When it holds, all solutions reach \(\delta_\xi\) by a time bounded by \(C\varepsilon^{\alpha_1}|\log\varepsilon|\). The proof follows the successive extinction of outer shells while controlling the loss of their inner neighbors. If the first decreasing gap occurs at shell \(k\), that shell instead disappears with exterior mass still present for the support-nonincreasing continuation. When \(k=1\), the obstruction holds for every continuation. Corollary 4.12 extends the classification to the full flow, with bounds uniform for \(0<\beta\leq\beta_0\) after the time factor \(\beta^{-1}\) is included.

An open obstruction to concentration.

For \(d\geq2\), Theorem 5.2 returns to the theoretical criterion and explicitly rules out its polynomial certificates on a nonempty open set. The set is described by two affine inequalities: the mass outside \(\xi\) is small, and the mass beyond the first shell exceeds the mass of that shell by a positive margin. At a minimum of a candidate polynomial on the corresponding compact polytope, the vector field provides an admissible direction and forces the wrong sign for the certificate. The same affine inequalities establish invariance for every global solution, which strengthens the failure of universal convergence to the exclusion of each individual convergent continuation. Corollary 5.3 places these open sets arbitrarily close to each Dirac mass, uniformly for the reduced equation and all \(\beta>0\).

Sections 3, 4, and 5 develop these three results in that order. The proofs of the principal results remain with their statements; the auxiliary proofs are collected in Appendix A.

2. Discrete transport geometry and complete solutions

Logarithmic mobility and the Riemannian metric

The mobility on an edge is the logarithmic mean \[\tag{2.1} \Theta(s,t)=\frac{s-t}{\log s-\log t} \quad(s,t>0,\ s\ne t),\qquad \Theta(s,s)=s,\] extended continuously by \(\Theta(s,0)=\Theta(0,s)=0\) for \(s\geq0\). We write \(\Theta(\rho)(x,y)=\Theta(\rho(x),\rho(y))\). For a vertex function \(\psi\) and an edge field \(\Phi\), set \[(\nabla\psi)(x,y)=\psi(y)-\psi(x),\qquad (\operatorname{div}\Phi)(x) =\frac12\sum_y a(x,y)\bigl(\Phi(x,y)-\Phi(y,x)\bigr).\] The symmetry of \(a\) gives the discrete integration-by-parts identity \[\tag{2.2} \langle\varphi,\operatorname{div}\Phi\rangle_{\rm euc} =-\frac12\sum_{x,y}a(x,y)\nabla\varphi(x,y)\Phi(x,y).\] The weighted edge pairing and its associated quadratic form are \[\langle\Phi,\Psi\rangle_\rho :=\frac12\sum_{x,y}a(x,y)\Theta(\rho(x),\rho(y)) \Phi(x,y)\Psi(x,y),\qquad \|\Phi\|_\rho^2:=\langle\Phi,\Phi\rangle_\rho.\] These expressions are used for real edge fields; complex identities below are obtained by complex-linear extension of the corresponding finite sums.

The discrete transport distance is defined dynamically by \[\tag{2.3} W(\rho_0,\rho_1)^2 =\inf_{\rho,\psi}\int_0^1\|\nabla\psi_t\|_{\rho_t}^2\,\mathrm dt,\] where \(\rho:[0,1]\to\mathcal P(X)\) is absolutely continuous, \(\psi\) is measurable, and the pair satisfies \[\tag{2.4} \dot\rho_t+\operatorname{div}\bigl(\Theta(\rho_t)\nabla\psi_t\bigr)=0 \quad\text{for almost every }t,\qquad \rho(0)=\rho_0,\quad\rho(1)=\rho_1.\] For the logarithmic mean, \(W\) is finite on the closed simplex and induces its usual topology; on \(\mathcal P_*(X)\) it is induced by a smooth Riemannian metric [10]. Our coordinates are probability masses. They agree with the usual formulation using densities relative to the uniform invariant measure after the change \(\widetilde\rho=|X|\rho\), by homogeneity of \(\Theta\).

To describe the metric explicitly, introduce the weighted Laplacian \[\Delta_\rho\psi :=\operatorname{div}\bigl(\Theta(\rho)\nabla\psi\bigr).\] For \(\rho\in\mathcal P_*(X)\), connectedness and (2.2) imply \[\ker\Delta_\rho=\mathbb R\mathbf1,\qquad \operatorname{Im}\Delta_\rho =T_\rho\mathcal P_*(X) =\left\{v\in\mathbb R^X:\sum_xv(x)=0\right\}.\] Indeed, \(-\langle\psi,\Delta_\rho\psi\rangle_{\rm euc} =\|\nabla\psi\|_\rho^2\), and this vanishes precisely for constant functions. Symmetry of \(\Delta_\rho\) then identifies its image. Each tangent vector therefore has a representation \(v=-\Delta_\rho\psi_v\), unique up to an additive constant in \(\psi_v\), and \[\tag{2.5} g_\rho(v,w):=\langle\nabla\psi_v,\nabla\psi_w\rangle_\rho\] defines the required Riemannian metric. This also fixes the normalization of (2.3): the factor \(1/2\) is already included in the edge pairing.

If \(\mathcal E\) is a smooth functional and \(D\mathcal E(\rho)\) is its Euclidean differential, identified with a vertex function, then \[\tag{2.6} \nabla_W\mathcal E(\rho)=-\Delta_\rho D\mathcal E(\rho).\] This follows by pairing the right-hand side with \(v=-\Delta_\rho\psi_v\) in (2.5) and applying (2.2). The logarithmic mean is distinguished by \(\Theta(s,t)(\log s-\log t)=s-t\): the descending gradient flow of \(\sum_x\rho(x)\log\rho(x)\) is consequently the discrete heat equation. Here the driving functional is instead an attractive interaction energy, and we follow its ascending gradient.

Interaction flows and the first-mode reduction

For \(h\in\{\sigma,k_\beta\}\), write \[U_\rho^h=h*\rho,\qquad U_\rho=U_\rho^\sigma.\] Since \(h\) is even, \(D E_h(\rho)=2U_\rho^h\). Thus, on \(\mathcal P_*(X)\), the ascending gradient equation is \[\tag{2.7} \dot\rho_t=\nabla_W E_h(\rho_t) =-2\operatorname{div}\bigl(\Theta(\rho_t)\nabla U_{\rho_t}^h\bigr).\] Its coordinate vector field is \[\tag{2.8} F_x^h(\rho) :=2\sum_y a(x,y)\Theta(\rho(x),\rho(y)) \bigl(U_\rho^h(x)-U_\rho^h(y)\bigr), \qquad x\in X.\] Unlike the Riemannian tensor, this vector field extends continuously to the whole simplex. All boundary statements in this paper refer to this coordinate extension. In particular, they do not assert a smooth Riemannian structure at boundary points.

The full unperturbed equation is \[\tag{2.9} \dot\rho_t=F^{k_\beta}(\rho_t),\qquad k_\beta=e^{\beta\sigma}, \qquad\beta>0.\] The expansion \(k_\beta=1+\beta\sigma+O(\beta^2)\), uniform on the finite set \(X\), gives \[E_\beta(\rho)=1+\beta J(\rho)+O(\beta^2),\qquad \beta^{-1}F^{k_\beta}(\rho)=F^\sigma(\rho)+O(\beta),\] uniformly for \(\rho\in\mathcal P(X)\). After the time rescaling \(\tau=\beta t\), the leading-order equation is therefore \[\tag{2.10} \dot\rho_t=F^\sigma(\rho_t) =-2\operatorname{div}\bigl(\Theta(\rho_t)\nabla(\sigma*\rho_t)\bigr).\] We call (2.10) the reduced flow. It is not the full equation evaluated at \(\beta=0\), whose kernel is constant and whose vector field vanishes. The Fourier representation \[\tag{2.11} U_\rho(x)=\sum_{j=1}^d \operatorname{Re}\bigl(e^{2\pi i x_j/N}A_j(\rho)\bigr), \qquad J(\rho)=\sum_{j=1}^d|A_j(\rho)|^2\] explains why the first Fourier modes govern this reduction.

Along any solution of the coordinate equation, including at boundary points, direct differentiation gives \[\tag{2.12} \frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}E_h(\rho_t) =4\|\nabla U_{\rho_t}^h\|_{\rho_t}^2 =2\sum_{x,y}a(x,y)\Theta(\rho_t(x),\rho_t(y)) \bigl(U_{\rho_t}^h(y)-U_{\rho_t}^h(x)\bigr)^2\geq0.\] The largest possible energy is attained exactly at the Dirac masses: \[J(\rho)\leq d,\qquad E_\beta(\rho)\leq e^{\beta d},\] with equality in either inequality if and only if \(\rho=\delta_\xi\) for some \(\xi\in X\). For \(J\), this follows because equality \(|A_j(\rho)|=1\) forces the \(j\)th coordinate to be constant on the support; for \(E_\beta\), it follows from \(k_\beta(z)<k_\beta(0)\) for \(z\ne0\). Energy monotonicity alone does not determine whether these maximizers are approached.

Forward-complete solutions and boundary continuations

Definition 2.1 (Forward-complete solutions). A forward-complete, or global, solution from \(\rho_0\in\mathcal P(X)\) is a curve \(\rho\in C^1([0,\infty);\mathbb R^X)\) satisfying \(\rho(0)=\rho_0\), \(\rho(t)\in\mathcal P(X)\), and \(\dot\rho(t)=F^h(\rho(t))\) for every \(t\geq0\). The collection of these curves is denoted by \(\mathcal S_h(\rho_0)\).

Completeness here concerns forward time only. The distinction between global solutions and a chosen continuation becomes relevant when a coordinate reaches zero.

Proposition 2.2 (Existence and the support-nonincreasing continuation). For either kernel, \(F^h\) is continuous and bounded on \(\mathcal P(X)\), smooth on the relative interior of each face, and satisfies \[\tag{2.13} \sum_xF_x^h(\rho)=0,\qquad \rho(x)=0\ \Longrightarrow\ F_x^h(\rho)=0.\] Every initial datum admits a global solution. Exactly one such solution has support nonincreasing with respect to set inclusion; it is denoted by \(\rho^{\mathrm{abs}}\).

Proof. Continuity of \(\Theta\) and compactness of the simplex give continuity and boundedness of \(F^h\). The two identities in (2.13) follow, respectively, by cancellation of opposite oriented edges and by \(\Theta(0,t)=0\).

Fix a nonempty \(S\subset X\) and the face \[\Delta_S=\{\rho\in\mathcal P(X):\rho(x)=0\text{ for }x\notin S\}.\] On its relative interior, the nonzero terms in the vector field involve only positive coordinates. Since \(\Theta\) is smooth on \((0,\infty)^2\), including the diagonal, the restricted vector field is smooth and tangent to the affine span of the face. Local existence and uniqueness hold until the solution reaches its relative boundary.

If the maximal interval in this face has a finite endpoint \(T\), boundedness of the vector field gives a limit \(\rho_T\in\Delta_S\) as \(t\uparrow T\). At least one coordinate in \(S\) must vanish there, since otherwise the local solution could be extended in the same relative interior. Restart the equation on \(\Delta_{\operatorname{supp}\rho_T}\), keeping all other coordinates zero. Each restart strictly decreases the support, so at most \(|X|-1\) restarts are possible. The pieces form a \(C^1\) curve because their derivatives converge to the same vector \(F^h(\rho_T)\) at each junction. A singleton face carries the constant solution. This constructs a global solution.

Any other solution with nonincreasing support agrees with this construction on the first relative interior by local uniqueness, and therefore has the same first boundary hitting time and value. Applying the same argument successively on the remaining faces proves uniqueness in this class. ◻

Remark 1. Tangency in (2.13) does not by itself make every face invariant under every solution of a continuous vector field. At a boundary point, local Lipschitz regularity is not guaranteed and delayed departures are not excluded by the equality \(F_x^h=0\). We consequently distinguish the support-nonincreasing continuation from arbitrary global solutions. When an invariance assertion is made for all solutions below, it is proved by a differential inequality.

First Fourier modes and the concentration question

We now restrict to the reduced flow. The first consequence of the energy identity is that positive first-mode energy excludes an interior limit.

Lemma 2.4 (No interior limit at positive energy). If \(J(\rho_0)>0\), no global solution of (2.10) from \(\rho_0\) converges to a point of \(\mathcal P_*(X)\).

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

At a boundary equilibrium, the potential need only be constant on each connected component of the support. This is the geometric source of possible stationary configurations with several surviving components. The next proposition refines energy monotonicity to each coordinate mode. Set \[\chi_j(x)=e^{-2\pi i x_j/N},\qquad \omega=e^{-2\pi i/N},\qquad M_{\ell,j}(\rho) =\sum_x\Theta(\rho(x),\rho(x+e_j))\chi_j(x)^\ell \quad(\ell=0,2).\]

Proposition 2.5 (Mode-by-mode monotonicity). For every global solution of (2.10) and every \(1\leq j\leq d\), \(t\mapsto|A_j(\rho_t)|^2\) is nondecreasing. More precisely, \[\tag{2.14} \begin{split} |A_j(\rho_t)|^2 &\geq |A_j(\rho_0)|^2 \exp\!\left(\frac{|\omega-1|^2}{d} \int_0^t\bigl(M_{0,j}(\rho_s)-|M_{2,j}(\rho_s)|\bigr)\,\mathrm ds\right),\\ |A_j(\rho_t)|^2 &\leq |A_j(\rho_0)|^2 \exp\!\left(\frac4d\left(1-\cos\frac{2\pi}{N}\right)t\right). \end{split}\] In particular, an initially zero first mode remains zero.

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

Corollary 2.6 (Arithmetic restriction on a limiting support). Assume that a global reduced solution converges to \(\rho_\infty\) and \(A_j(\rho_0)\ne0\). Then some \(a_j\in\mathbb Z/N\mathbb Z\) satisfies \[\rho_\infty(x)>0,\quad\rho_\infty(x+e_j)>0 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad 2x_j\equiv2a_j\pmod N.\]

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

Since every first Fourier mode has modulus one at a Dirac mass, Proposition 2.5 supplies the necessary condition \[A_j(\rho_0)\ne0\qquad(1\leq j\leq d)\] for convergence to a Dirac mass. It does not supply a sufficient condition. For example, if \(N\) is even, let \[p_\varepsilon(k)=\frac{1-\varepsilon}{2} \bigl(\mathbf1_{\{0\}}(k)+\mathbf1_{\{1\}}(k)\bigr) +\frac\varepsilon N, \qquad \rho_0(x)=\prod_{j=1}^dp_\varepsilon(x_j),\qquad0<\varepsilon<1.\] This is a strictly positive density with all \(A_j(\rho_0)\ne0\). The reflection \(R_jx=(x_1,\ldots,1-x_j,\ldots,x_d)\) preserves the kernel, the graph, and the initial density. By uniqueness within the support-nonincreasing class, it preserves \(\rho^{\mathrm{abs}}_t\) for all \(t\). A Dirac limit would therefore require \(2\xi_j\equiv1\pmod N\), which is impossible for even \(N\).

This elementary obstruction raises the main question: which conditions on the initial density characterize concentration, and which of them can be checked in a useful explicit form? The next section answers the first question through polynomial certificates valid for both kernels. The multiscale analysis then provides a sharp, directly checkable classification for a specified family of initial data. Finally, the open obstruction shows that failure of concentration persists under perturbations of the initial density, including arbitrarily close to a Dirac mass.

3. A theoretical characterization of Dirac convergence

We first address convergence without assuming that the initial density is close to a Dirac mass or belongs to a prescribed hierarchy of scales. Because the vector field is only continuous at the boundary, the relevant basin consists of initial data for which every global continuation converges to the same Dirac mass. We characterize this basin by a countable family of polynomial inequalities on the simplex.

The argument has two parts. An alternative for continuous vector fields identifies the absence of a trajectory confined to a compact set with the existence of a polynomial escape certificate. A local monotonicity property near a Dirac mass then turns escape from a sequence of compact sets into convergence. Both parts apply to the reduced kernel \(h=\sigma\) and, for every fixed \(\beta>0\), to the full kernel \(h=k_\beta\).

For a polynomial \(P\) on \(\mathbb R^X\), its Lie derivative along \(F^h\) is \[\tag{3.1} \mathcal L_{F^h}P(\rho) :=\sum_{x\in X}F_x^h(\rho)\,\partial_{\rho(x)}P(\rho).\] Thus all certificate inequalities below are evaluated directly on the simplex; they impose no asymptotic condition on a trajectory.

Lemma 3.1 (\(C^1\) approximation on a box). Let \(B\subset\mathbb{R}^m\) be a compact box, and let \(u\) be \(C^1\) on a neighborhood of \(B\). There exist real polynomials \(p_j\) such that \[\tag{3.2} \sup_B|p_j-u|+\sup_B\|\nabla p_j-\nabla u\| \longrightarrow0.\] For any prescribed strictly positive error tolerance, the approximating polynomial may be chosen with rational coefficients.

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

A polynomial alternative for confinement and escape

For the next two results, let \(S\subset\mathbb R^m\) be a nonempty compact convex set, let \(r\in S\), let \(K\subset S\) be compact, and let \(F\in C(S;\mathbb R^m)\). For every real polynomial \(p\), write \[\mathcal L_Fp(x):=F(x)\cdot\nabla p(x), \qquad B_F:=\sup_{x\in S}\|F(x)\|<\infty.\] A global solution is understood as a \(C^1\) curve with values in \(S\). The set \(K\) may be empty unless explicitly excluded.

Proposition 3.2 (Discounted occupation measures and existence of a trajectory). Assume \(K \neq \emptyset\). The following assertions are equivalent:

  1. there exists \(z\in C^1([0,+\infty);\mathbb{R}^m)\) such that \[z(0)=r,\qquad z(t)\in K,\qquad \dot z(t)=F(z(t))\quad(t\ge0);\]

  2. there exists a Borel probability measure \(\mu\) on \(K\) such that \[\tag{3.3} \int_K(p-\mathcal L_{F}p) d\mu=p(r) \qquad\text{for every real polynomial }p.\]

In (ii), it suffices to test all monomials.

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

Theorem 3.3 (A necessary and sufficient polynomial escape certificate). With the preceding notation, the following assertions are equivalent:

  1. no global solution starting from \(r\) remains in \(K\) for all time;

  2. there exists a real polynomial \(P\) such that \[\tag{3.4} P(r)<0,\qquad P(x)-\mathcal{L}_F P(x)\ge1\quad(x\in K);\]

  3. there exists a polynomial with rational coefficients satisfying (3.4).

No uniqueness or Lipschitz assumption on \(F\) is required.

Proof of Theorem 3.3. If \(K=\varnothing\), (i) is immediate, and \(P\equiv-1\) works, since the second inequality is vacuous. Assume henceforth that \(K\ne\varnothing\).

\(\textbf{Sufficiency of the certificate.}\) The implication (iii)\(\Rightarrow\)(ii) is immediate. Assume (ii), and suppose, for a contradiction, that a solution \(z\) remains in \(K\). Then \[\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}\bigl(e^{-t}P(z(t))\bigr) =-e^{-t}(P-\mathcal{L}_F P)(z(t))\le-e^{-t}.\] Integrating and multiplying by \(e^t\) gives \[\tag{3.5} P(z(t))\le1+e^t(P(r)-1).\] The right-hand side tends to \(-\infty\), whereas \(P\) is bounded on \(K\). This is a contradiction. Thus (ii)\(\Rightarrow\)(i).

\(\textbf{Necessity through finitely many constraints.}\) Assume (i). By Proposition 3.2, no probability measure on \(K\) satisfies all the identities (3.3). The space \(\mathcal P(K)\) of Borel probability measures on \(K\) is compact for weak convergence, since \(K\) is a compact metric space. For every monomial \(p\), the set \[\mathcal M_p=\left\{\mu\in\mathcal P(K): \int(p-\mathcal{L}_F p)\mathrm d\mu=p(r)\right\}\] is closed, because the integrand is continuous on \(K\). If every finite intersection of the sets \(\mathcal M_p\) were nonempty, their full intersection would be nonempty by compactness. Hence there exist monomials \(p_1,\ldots,p_\ell\) such that \[\bigcap_{i=1}^\ell\mathcal M_{p_i}=\varnothing.\] In other words, the vector \(v=(p_1(r),\ldots,p_\ell(r))\) does not belong to the compact convex set \[C=\left\{\left(\int(p_i-\mathcal{L}_F p_i)\mathrm d\mu\right)_{i=1}^\ell: \mu\in\mathcal P(K)\right\}\subset\mathbb{R}^\ell.\] Strict separation of a point from a compact convex set yields \(a=(a_1,\ldots,a_\ell)\) such that \[a\cdot v<\min_{w\in C}a\cdot w.\] Set \(q=\sum_{i=1}^\ell a_ip_i\). We obtain \[\tag{3.6} q(r)<\min_{\mu\in\mathcal P(K)}\int(q-\mathcal{L}_F q)\mathrm d\mu =\min_{x\in K}(q(x)-\mathcal{L}_F q(x)).\] The last equality holds because the integral of a continuous function against a probability measure is at least its minimum, and a Dirac mass at a minimizer attains that minimum.

Write \[a_0=q(r),\qquad b_0=\min_K(q-\mathcal{L}_F q),\qquad g=b_0-a_0>0.\] Defining \[P_0=\frac4g\left(q-\frac{a_0+b_0}{2}\right),\] we have \[\tag{3.7} P_0(r)=-2,\qquad P_0-\mathcal{L}_F P_0\ge2\quad\text{on }K.\] The normalization uses \(\mathcal{L}_F c=0\) for constants \(c\).

\(\textbf{Passing to rational coefficients.}\) Choose a polynomial \(P\) with the same monomials as \(P_0\) and sufficiently close rational coefficients that \[\sup_S|P-P_0|<\frac12, \qquad \sup_K|P-P_0|+B_F\sup_K\|\nabla P-\nabla P_0\|<\frac12.\] This is possible by density of the rationals in the finite-dimensional coefficient space. Then \(P(r)<-3/2<0\), and, on \(K\), \[P-\mathcal{L}_F P \ge(P_0-\mathcal{L}_F P_0)-|P-P_0| -B_F\|\nabla P-\nabla P_0\|>\frac32\ge1.\] The polynomial with rational coefficients satisfies (3.4). This proves (i)\(\Rightarrow\)(iii) and completes the proof. ◻

The universal basin of a Dirac mass

We now apply the escape alternative to the interaction field \(F^h\). For \(\xi\in X\), define \[\tag{3.8} \mathcal B^\forall_{h,\xi} =\left\{\rho_0\in\mathcal{P}_*(X): \forall\rho\in\mathcal{S}_h(\rho_0),\quad \rho(t)\longrightarrow\delta_\xi\right\}.\] By Proposition 2.2, the set of global solutions is nonempty for every initial datum.

For \(\xi\in X\), write \(q_\xi(\rho):=1-\rho(\xi)\). Define \[\tag{3.9} \begin{gathered} \lambda_h:=h(0)-h(e_1)>0, \qquad L_h:=\max_{u\sim v}|h(u)-h(v)|,\qquad q_h:=\frac{\lambda_h}{2(\lambda_h+L_h)}. \end{gathered}\] For either kernel, the central edge gap is the same in every coordinate direction, and \(0<q_h\leq1/4\). These constants are independent of \(\xi\). If \(q=q_\xi(\rho)\leq q_h\), write \(\rho=(1-q)\delta_\xi+\mu\) with \(\mu\geq0\) and \(\mu(X)=q\). For every \(y\sim\xi\), translation invariance gives \[U_\rho^h(\xi)-U_\rho^h(y) \geq(1-q)\lambda_h-qL_h\geq\frac{\lambda_h}{2}.\] Consequently \(\mathcal L_{F^h}q_\xi=-F_\xi^h\leq0\) whenever \(q_\xi\leq q_h\). Along any global solution, a first-exit argument therefore yields \[\tag{3.10} q_\xi(\rho_s)<q_h \quad\Longrightarrow\quad q_\xi(\rho_t)\leq q_\xi(\rho_s) \quad(t\geq s).\] Indeed, integration gives this bound on the maximal interval starting at \(s\) on which \(q_\xi<q_h\), and continuity prevents a finite exit from that interval. This argument holds on the closed simplex and uses no uniqueness assumption.

Fix the following thresholds and compact sets, independently of the initial datum: \tag{3.11} \begin{align*} \varepsilon_{h,n}&:=\frac{q_h}{2^n},\qquad n\geq1,\\ K_{h,\xi,n}&:=\{\rho\in\mathcal P(X):\rho(\xi)\leq1-\varepsilon_{h,n}\}\\ &=\{\rho\in\mathcal P(X):q_\xi(\rho)\geq\varepsilon_{h,n}\}. \end{align*} These sets are compact; the thresholds tend to zero and are all strictly smaller than \(q_h\).

Theorem 3.4 (A necessary and sufficient condition on the initial datum). For every \(\rho_0\in\mathcal{P}_*(X)\), the following assertions are equivalent:

  1. \(\rho_0\in\mathcal B^\forall_{h,\xi}\);

  2. for every integer \(n\ge1\), there exists \(P_n\in \mathbb{Q}[(\rho(x))_{x\in X}]\) such that \[\tag{3.12} \quad P_n(\rho_0)<0,\qquad P_n(\rho)-\mathcal L_{F^h}P_n(\rho)\ge1 \quad\text{for every }\rho\in K_{h,\xi,n}. \quad\]

No assumption of proximity, scale separation, or shell structure is imposed on \(\rho_0\). The same statement holds for an initial datum in the closed simplex if the basin is defined on \(\mathcal{P}(X)\).

Proof. Assume (i), and fix \(n\ge1\). A solution remaining in \(K_{h,\xi,n}\) for all time would satisfy \(q_\xi(\rho(t))\ge\varepsilon_{h,n}>0\) for every \(t\), and could not converge to \(\delta_\xi\). Thus no such solution starting from \(\rho_0\) exists. Apply Theorem 3.3 with \[S=\mathcal P(X)\subset\mathbb R^X,\quad F=F^h,\quad r=\rho_0,\quad K=K_{h,\xi,n}.\] All its hypotheses hold: the simplex is compact and convex, the vector field is continuous, and \(K\) is compact. We obtain the polynomial \(P_n\) with rational coefficients in (3.12). Since \(n\) was arbitrary, this proves (ii).

Conversely, assume (ii), and fix a global solution \(\rho\in\mathcal{S}_h(\rho_0)\). For each \(n\), the sufficiency direction of Theorem 3.3 prevents it from remaining in \(K_{h,\xi,n}\) for all time. Hence there exists a time \(s_n\) such that \[q_\xi(\rho(s_n))<\varepsilon_{h,n}<q_h.\] By (3.10), \[q_\xi(\rho(t))\le q_\xi(\rho(s_n))<\varepsilon_{h,n} \qquad(t\ge s_n).\] Given \(\eta>0\), choose \(n\) such that \(\varepsilon_{h,n}<\eta\). The preceding inequality shows that \(q_\xi(\rho(t))<\eta\) for every \(t\ge s_n\). Thus \(q_\xi(\rho(t))\to0\). Finally, \[\tag{3.13} \|\rho(t)-\delta_\xi\|_{\ell^1(X)} =|1-\rho(t,\xi)|+\sum_{x\ne\xi}\rho(t,x) =2q_\xi(\rho(t))\longrightarrow0.\] Since the solution was arbitrary, (i) follows.

No step requires strict positivity of \(\rho_0\), so the same proof applies on the closed simplex. ◻

The characterization is global and exact, but it does not provide a uniform bound on the degrees of the certificates. Moreover, although the certificates are polynomials, their Lie derivatives contain the logarithmic mobility. The next section gives explicit conditions on a multiscale class of initial densities, together with quantitative extinction times.

4. A practical criterion: multiscale classification

The polynomial characterization applies to arbitrary initial data, but it does not by itself display a simple family in the basin of a Dirac mass. We now identify such a family through the relative sizes of the masses on successive graph-distance shells. The resulting criterion also explains why concentrating most of the mass at one site does not suffice: the intermediate shells must survive long enough to transmit the outer mass.

Throughout this section, the flow is the reduced equation (2.10), and \(U_\rho:=\sigma*\rho\). Fix \(\xi\in X\) and set \[\tag{4.1} r_\xi(x):=\sum_{j=1}^d \min\{|x_j-\xi_j|,N-|x_j-\xi_j|\},\qquad R:=d\left\lfloor\frac N2\right\rfloor.\] For \(0\leq m\leq R\), let \[S_m^\xi:=\{x\in X:r_\xi(x)=m\}.\] Thus \(S_0^\xi=\{\xi\}\). We omit the superscript when the centre is fixed. An edge is oriented inward by writing \(y\prec_\xi x\) when \(x\sim y\) and \(r_\xi(y)=r_\xi(x)-1\). Every point of a noncentral shell has an inward neighbour.

The classification theorem

Fix an exponent sequence \[\tag{4.2} 0=\alpha_0<\alpha_1<\cdots<\alpha_R, \qquad \Delta_m:=\alpha_m-\alpha_{m-1}.\] Its strict discrete convexity is the condition \[\tag{4.3} \alpha_{m+1}+\alpha_{m-1}-2\alpha_m =\Delta_{m+1}-\Delta_m>0 \qquad(1\leq m<R).\]

Definition 4.1 (Multiscale shell condition). For \(K>1\) and \(0<\varepsilon<1\), a density \(\rho_0\in\mathcal P_*(X)\) satisfies \((H_\alpha)_{\xi,K,\varepsilon}\) if \[\tag{4.4} K^{-1}\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}\leq\rho_0(x) \leq K\varepsilon^{\alpha_m} \qquad(1\leq m\leq R,\ x\in S_m^\xi).\] The remaining coordinate is fixed by \(\rho_0(\xi)=1-\sum_{x\ne\xi}\rho_0(x)\).

For fixed \(N,d,K,\alpha\), the central mass is positive when \(\varepsilon\) is sufficiently small. No symmetry within a shell is required. The order of these choices will remain fixed: first \(N,d,K,\alpha\), then a sufficiently small \(\varepsilon\), and finally any datum satisfying (4.4).

Theorem 4.2 (Multiscale classification away from critical exponent gaps). Fix \(N\geq3\), \(d\geq2\), \(K>1\), and an exponent sequence as in (4.2). Assume that \[\Delta_{m+1}\ne\Delta_m\qquad(1\leq m<R).\] There exist \(\varepsilon_*\in(0,1)\) and \(C_*,c_*>0\), depending only on \(N,d,K,\alpha\), such that the following assertions hold. Let \(\xi\in X\), \(0<\varepsilon<\varepsilon_*\), and let \(\rho_0\in\mathcal P_*(X)\) satisfy \((H_\alpha)_{\xi,K,\varepsilon}\). Denote by \(\rho^{\mathrm{abs}}\) its support-nonincreasing global solution. The following conditions are equivalent:

  1. \(\Delta_1<\Delta_2<\cdots<\Delta_R\);

  2. \(\rho_t^{\mathrm{abs}}\to\delta_\xi\) as \(t\to\infty\);

  3. every global solution starting from \(\rho_0\) converges to \(\delta_\xi\) as \(t\to\infty\).

When these conditions hold, every such solution reaches \(\delta_\xi\) at a time \[T\leq C_*\varepsilon^{\alpha_1}|\log\varepsilon|\] and remains there for all later times.

If (i) fails, let \[k:=\min\{m\in\{1,\ldots,R-1\}:\Delta_{m+1}<\Delta_m\}.\] There exists \(T_k\leq C_*\varepsilon^{\Delta_k}|\log\varepsilon|\) such that, for all \(t\geq T_k\), \[\sum_{x\in S_k^\xi}\rho_t^{\mathrm{abs}}(x)=0,\] \[\sum_{r_\xi(x)\geq k+1}\rho_t^{\mathrm{abs}}(x) =\sum_{r_\xi(x)\geq k+1}\rho_{T_k}^{\mathrm{abs}}(x) \geq c_*\varepsilon^{\alpha_{k+1}},\] and \[\inf_{z\in X}\|\rho_t^{\mathrm{abs}}-\delta_z\|_{\ell^1(X)} \geq c_*\varepsilon^{\alpha_{k+1}}.\] If \(k=1\), these conclusions hold for every global solution, with \(T_1\) allowed to depend on that solution.

The theorem characterizes the universal basin within this multiscale class. For a first decreasing gap at \(k>1\), its negative conclusion uses the specified support-nonincreasing continuation; it makes no assertion that all other boundary continuations have the same limit. Equal consecutive gaps are excluded. The explicit choice \(\alpha_m=2^m-1\) satisfies the strict-convexity condition and gives a collapse time bounded by \(C_*\varepsilon|\log\varepsilon|\).

Flux estimates and extinction of shells

All constants below are independent of \(\varepsilon\) and of the chosen solution. Their dependence is restricted to \(N,d\) and, where indicated, \(K,\alpha\). The auxiliary estimates require the strict increase of the exponents, but not the strict increase of their gaps.

Lemma 4.3 (Bounds for the logarithmic mean). The logarithmic mean is nondecreasing in each variable on \([0,\infty)^2\). It also satisfies the following estimates.

  1. If \(0<s\leq a/2\leq1/2\), then \[\tag{4.5} \Theta(s,a)\geq\frac{a}{2|\log s|}.\]

  2. For \(A\geq1\) and \(0\leq b<a\), there are constants \(C,\varepsilon_0>0\), depending only on \(A,a,b\), such that \[\tag{4.6} \left. \begin{array}{c} 0\leq s\leq A\varepsilon^a\\ 0\leq t\leq A\varepsilon^b \end{array}\right\} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \Theta(s,t)\leq C\frac{\varepsilon^b}{|\log\varepsilon|} \qquad(0<\varepsilon<\varepsilon_0).\] When \(a=b\), one has instead \[\tag{4.7} \Theta(s,t)\leq A\varepsilon^a.\]

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

The next comparison controls the inflow from an outer shell even when the mass of the intermediate shell approaches zero.

Lemma 4.4 (Joint small-mass comparison). For every \(n\geq1\) and \(A>0\), \[\tag{4.8} \frac{\Theta(p,r)}{\Theta(p/n,A)}\longrightarrow0 \qquad\text{as }(p,r)\longrightarrow(0,0),\quad p>0.\] In particular, for every \(\varepsilon_0>0\) there exist \(\bar p_0,\eta_0>0\) such that \[\tag{4.9} \Theta(p,r)\leq\varepsilon_0\Theta(p/n,A) \qquad(0<p\leq\bar p_0,\ 0\leq r\leq2\eta_0).\]

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

Lemma 4.5 (Discrete slope at a Dirac mass). Let \(V_\xi(x):=\sigma(x-\xi)\). There is a constant \(\kappa_N>0\) such that \[\tag{4.10} V_\xi(y)-V_\xi(x)\geq\kappa_N \qquad(y\prec_\xi x).\] One may take \[\kappa_N:=\min_{1\leq q\leq\lfloor N/2\rfloor} \left\{\cos\left(\frac{2\pi(q-1)}N\right) -\cos\left(\frac{2\pi q}N\right)\right\}.\]

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

Lemma 4.6 (Uniform orientation of radial edges). There exists \(q_*=q_*(N,d)>0\) such that \[\tag{4.11} 1-\rho(\xi)\leq q_* \quad\Longrightarrow\quad U_\rho(y)-U_\rho(x)\geq\frac{\kappa_N}2 \quad(y\prec_\xi x)\] for every \(\rho\in\mathcal P(X)\).

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

For \(1\leq m\leq R\), define the tail mass \[Q_m(t):=\sum_{r_\xi(x)\geq m}\rho_t(x), \qquad Q_0(t):=1,\qquad Q_{R+1}(t):=0.\] Summation of the coordinate equation cancels the fluxes internal to a tail. Its evolution is therefore controlled entirely by the edges joining \(S_m\) to \(S_{m-1}\).

Lemma 4.7 (Monotonicity, upper bounds, and persistence of tails). Let \(\rho\) be a global solution and \(I\subset[0,\infty)\) an interval on which \(1-\rho_t(\xi)\leq q_*\). Then, for \(1\leq m\leq R\), \[\tag{4.12} \dot Q_m(t)\leq-\frac{\kappa_N}{2d} \sum_{\substack{x\in S_m,\ y\in S_{m-1}\\x\sim y}} \Theta(\rho_t(x),\rho_t(y))\leq0 \quad\text{for almost every }t\in I.\] If \(0\in I\) and \(\rho_0\) satisfies \((H_\alpha)_{\xi,K,\varepsilon}\), then, with \(C_H:=K|X|\), \[\tag{4.13} Q_m(t)\leq Q_m(0)\leq C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_m} \qquad(t\in I).\] Consequently, \[\tag{4.14} \rho_t(x)\leq C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_m} \qquad(x\in S_m,\ t\in I).\] Finally, if \([s,u]\subset I\) and \(Q_m(s)=0\), then \(Q_m(t)=0\) for all \(t\in[s,u]\).

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

Choose the concentration threshold so that \[\tag{4.15} C_H\varepsilon_*^{\alpha_1}\leq\frac{q_*}2.\] The initial datum then lies strictly inside the region of radial orientation. Tail monotonicity prevents it from leaving this region.

Lemma 4.8 (Persistent proximity to the central Dirac mass). Under (4.15), every global solution starting from a datum satisfying \((H_\alpha)_{\xi,K,\varepsilon}\), with \(0<\varepsilon<\varepsilon_*\), satisfies \[1-\rho_t(\xi)\leq q_*\qquad(t\geq0).\] Hence Lemma 4.6, Lemma 4.7 apply for all times.

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

To compare the extinction of an outer shell with the survival of its inner neighbours, set \[\tag{4.16} L_i(\varepsilon):=c_K\varepsilon^{\alpha_i}, \qquad c_K:=\frac1{2K},\qquad 0\leq i\leq R.\] In particular, \(L_0=1/(2K)\). The next estimate bounds the loss of an individual site, including possible transfers within its own shell.

Lemma 4.9 (Maximum rate of loss from a shell). There exist \(C_L,\varepsilon_L>0\), depending only on \(N,d,K,\alpha\), such that, for \(0<\varepsilon<\varepsilon_L\), every global solution starting from \((H_\alpha)_{\xi,K,\varepsilon}\) satisfies \[\tag{4.17} \dot\rho_t(z)\geq -C_L\frac{\varepsilon^{\alpha_{i-1}}}{|\log\varepsilon|} \qquad(z\in S_i,\ i\geq1)\] for almost every \(t\geq0\). At the centre, \(\dot\rho_t(\xi)\geq0\).

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

Lemma 4.10 (Extinction of an outermost occupied shell). There exist \(C_E,c_E,\varepsilon_E>0\), depending only on \(N,d,K,\alpha\), with the following property. Let \(0<\varepsilon<\varepsilon_E\), let \(\rho\) be a global solution starting from \((H_\alpha)_{\xi,K,\varepsilon}\), and fix \(m\in\{1,\ldots,R\}\). Suppose that \(I\subset[0,\infty)\) is an interval on which \[\tag{4.18} Q_{m+1}(t)=0\] and \[\tag{4.19} \rho_t(y)\geq L_{m-1}(\varepsilon) \qquad(y\in S_{m-1}).\] Assume also that \(1-\rho_t(\xi)\leq q_*\) up to \(\sup I\). Writing \(q_m(t):=\sum_{x\in S_m}\rho_t(x)\), one has \[\tag{4.20} \dot q_m(t)\leq -c_E\frac{\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}}{|\log q_m(t)|}\] for almost every \(t\in I\) with \(q_m(t)>0\). If \[[s,s+C_E\varepsilon^{\Delta_m}|\log\varepsilon|]\subset I,\] then \(q_m\) reaches zero at a time \(T_m\geq s\) satisfying \[\tag{4.21} T_m-s\leq C_E\varepsilon^{\Delta_m}|\log\varepsilon|.\]

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

The converse part of the classification requires the corresponding estimate before the exterior tail has disappeared. Its proof uses Lemma 4.4 to compare the two fluxes across an intermediate shell uniformly as that shell empties.

Lemma 4.11 (Extinction in the presence of an outer tail). There exist \(C_F,c_F,\varepsilon_F>0\), depending only on \(N,d,K,\alpha\), such that the following holds for \(0<\varepsilon<\varepsilon_F\). Let \(\rho\) be any global solution starting from \((H_\alpha)_{\xi,K,\varepsilon}\), and fix \(m\in\{1,\ldots,R-1\}\). On an interval \(I\subset[0,\infty)\), assume only the inner lower bound \[\tag{4.22} \rho_t(y)\geq L_{m-1}(\varepsilon) \qquad(y\in S_{m-1},\ t\in I).\] No vanishing condition is imposed on \(Q_{m+1}\). Then \(p_m(t):=\sum_{x\in S_m}\rho_t(x)\) is nonincreasing on \(I\), and \[\tag{4.23} \dot p_m(t)\leq -c_F\frac{\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}}{|\log p_m(t)|}\] for almost every \(t\in I\) with \(p_m(t)>0\). If \[[s,s+C_F\varepsilon^{\Delta_m}|\log\varepsilon|]\subset I,\] then \(p_m\) vanishes on this interval and remains zero on the remainder of \(I\). Moreover, for \(s\leq t\) in \(I\), \[\tag{4.24} 0\leq Q_{m+1}(s)-Q_{m+1}(t) \leq C_F\frac{\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}}{|\log\varepsilon|}(t-s).\]

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

Hierarchical proof of the classification

Proof of Theorem 4.2. Global solutions and the support-nonincreasing continuation exist by Proposition 2.2. We first work with an arbitrary global solution. All estimates remain valid at boundary points; no uniqueness of an arbitrary boundary continuation is used.

Step 1: increasing gaps and the choice of threshold. Assume \(\Delta_1<\cdots<\Delta_R\). Decrease \(\varepsilon_*\) so that (4.15) and all preceding auxiliary estimates hold, and so that \(\rho_0(\xi)>1/2>L_0\). Write \[D_m(\varepsilon):=C_E\varepsilon^{\Delta_m}|\log\varepsilon|.\] For each \(1\leq i<R\), impose \[\tag{4.25} C_LC_E\sum_{m=i+1}^R \varepsilon^{\alpha_{i-1}+\Delta_m} \leq\frac1{4K}\varepsilon^{\alpha_i} \qquad(0<\varepsilon<\varepsilon_*).\] These finitely many conditions are compatible because \[\alpha_{i-1}+\Delta_m-\alpha_i =\Delta_m-\Delta_i>0\qquad(m>i).\] They quantify the separation between the time needed to empty an outer shell and the time over which an inner site could lose a fixed fraction of its initial mass.

Step 2: descending extinction with stopping times. Set \(\tau_{R+1}=0\). We construct \(\tau_R,\ldots,\tau_1\) such that \[\tag{4.26} Q_m(t)=0\qquad(t\geq\tau_m),\] \[\tag{4.27} 0\leq\tau_m-\tau_{m+1}\leq D_m(\varepsilon),\] and \[\tag{4.28} \rho_{\tau_m}(z)>L_i(\varepsilon) \qquad(0\leq i<m,\ z\in S_i).\] At time \(\tau_{R+1}=0\), all noncentral masses exceed their thresholds by (4.4), and the central inequality follows from the choice of \(\varepsilon_*\). The initial tail condition is \(Q_{R+1}=0\).

Suppose that \(\tau_{m+1}\) has been constructed. Tail persistence gives \(Q_{m+1}(t)=0\) for \(t\geq\tau_{m+1}\). If \(Q_m(\tau_{m+1})=0\), set \(\tau_m=\tau_{m+1}\); all induction properties follow immediately. Otherwise, define \[\begin{aligned} \theta_m:=\inf\{t\geq\tau_{m+1}:\;&Q_m(t)=0\ \text{or}\ \\ &\rho_t(z)=L_i(\varepsilon) \text{ for some }i<m,\ z\in S_i\}. \end{aligned}\] Before \(\theta_m\), the exterior tail has vanished and all inner sites remain above their lower thresholds. Thus \(Q_m=q_m:=\sum_{x\in S_m}\rho_t(x)\) on the current step, and Lemma 4.10 applies on every compact subinterval of \([\tau_{m+1},\theta_m)\). For \(m=1\), its inner lower bound follows from the nondecreasing central mass.

The extinction estimate implies \[\tag{4.29} \theta_m-\tau_{m+1}\leq D_m(\varepsilon), \qquad\theta_m<\infty.\] Indeed, if the stopping time were larger, the hypotheses of Lemma 4.10 would hold on the entire interval of length \(D_m(\varepsilon)\), forcing \(Q_m\) to vanish before the first stopping event. Continuity ensures that at least one defining event occurs at \(\theta_m\).

We now rule out an inner threshold event, including simultaneous occurrence with extinction. The centre cannot reach \(L_0\), because its mass is nondecreasing. If \(1\leq i<m\) and \(z\in S_i\), the completed stages and (4.29) give \[\theta_m\leq\sum_{k=m}^R D_k(\varepsilon).\] Integrating (4.17) over \([0,\theta_m]\) therefore yields \[\begin{aligned} \rho_0(z)-\rho_{\theta_m}(z) &\leq\int_0^{\theta_m}(\dot\rho_t(z))_-\,\mathrm dt\\ &\leq C_L\frac{\varepsilon^{\alpha_{i-1}}}{|\log\varepsilon|} \sum_{k=m}^R D_k(\varepsilon)\\ &\leq C_LC_E\sum_{k=i+1}^R \varepsilon^{\alpha_{i-1}+\Delta_k} \leq\frac1{4K}\varepsilon^{\alpha_i}. \end{aligned}\] Here \(v_-:=\max\{-v,0\}\); integrating the negative part controls the net loss even if the coordinate also receives mass. It follows that \[\rho_{\theta_m}(z)\geq \frac{3}{4K}\varepsilon^{\alpha_i} >L_i(\varepsilon).\] Hence the only possible stopping event is \(Q_m(\theta_m)=0\). Set \(\tau_m:=\theta_m\). The duration estimate follows from (4.29); tail monotonicity gives (4.26); and the strict inequalities just proved give (4.28). This completes the induction.

At \(T:=\tau_1\), all noncentral masses vanish, so \(\rho_T=\delta_\xi\). The persistence of \(Q_1=0\) shows that the solution remains there. Finally, \[T\leq C_E\sum_{m=1}^R\varepsilon^{\Delta_m}|\log\varepsilon| \leq C_*\varepsilon^{\alpha_1}|\log\varepsilon|,\] because \(\Delta_m\geq\Delta_1=\alpha_1\). The solution was arbitrary; thus (i) implies (iii), with the asserted finite-time bound.

Step 3: a first decreasing gap. Suppose now that (i) fails. Since consecutive gaps are unequal, the index \(k\) in the statement satisfies \[\tag{4.30} \Delta_1<\cdots<\Delta_k, \qquad\Delta_{k+1}<\Delta_k.\] The first chain imposes no condition when \(k=1\). We show first, for every global solution, that \(S_k\) becomes empty while positive mass remains outside it.

Shrink \(\varepsilon_*\) so that Lemma 4.9, Lemma 4.11 apply, the central mass stays above \(1/2\), and \[\tag{4.31} C_LC_F\varepsilon^{\alpha_{i-1}+\Delta_k} \leq\frac1{4K}\varepsilon^{\alpha_i} \qquad(1\leq i<k).\] This is possible because \(\Delta_k>\Delta_i\) for \(i<k\). Put \(D_k^F:=C_F\varepsilon^{\Delta_k}|\log\varepsilon|\) and \(p_k(t):=\sum_{x\in S_k}\rho_t(x)\). Define \[\begin{aligned} \theta:=\inf\{t\geq0:\;&p_k(t)=0\ \text{or}\ \\ &\rho_t(z)=L_i(\varepsilon) \text{ for some }i<k,\ z\in S_i\}. \end{aligned}\] All inner coordinates start strictly above their thresholds. On \([0,\theta)\), the inner lower bound in Lemma 4.11 holds for \(S_{k-1}\); for \(k=1\), it holds because the central mass is nondecreasing. The same stopping-time argument as before gives \[\tag{4.32} \theta\leq D_k^F<\infty.\] For \(1\leq i<k\), integrating the loss estimate and using (4.31) yields \[\rho_\theta(z)\geq\rho_0(z) -C_L\frac{\varepsilon^{\alpha_{i-1}}}{|\log\varepsilon|}D_k^F \geq\frac{3}{4K}\varepsilon^{\alpha_i}>L_i(\varepsilon).\] The central threshold is again impossible. Thus \(p_k(\theta)=0\); write \(T_k:=\theta\).

To estimate the mass that has crossed \(S_k\) before this time, apply (4.24) on \([0,t]\), \(t<T_k\), and pass to \(T_k\) by continuity: \[Q_{k+1}(0)-Q_{k+1}(T_k) \leq C_F\frac{\varepsilon^{\alpha_k}}{|\log\varepsilon|}T_k \leq C_F^2\varepsilon^{\alpha_k+\Delta_k}.\] The initial lower bounds give \(Q_{k+1}(0)\geq K^{-1}\varepsilon^{\alpha_{k+1}}\). Moreover, \[\alpha_k+\Delta_k-\alpha_{k+1} =\Delta_k-\Delta_{k+1}>0.\] We can therefore require \[\tag{4.33} C_F^2\varepsilon^{\alpha_k+\Delta_k} \leq\frac1{2K}\varepsilon^{\alpha_{k+1}},\] which implies \[\tag{4.34} Q_{k+1}(T_k)\geq\frac1{2K}\varepsilon^{\alpha_{k+1}}>0.\] Up to this time, the argument applies to every global solution.

Step 4: persistence and the boundary quantifiers. For \(\rho^{\mathrm{abs}}\), every coordinate of \(S_k\) remains zero after \(T_k\). Each edge crossing the boundary of \(\{r_\xi\geq k+1\}\) has an endpoint in \(S_k\), so its logarithmic mobility vanishes. The boundary-flux identity then gives \[Q_{k+1}(t)=Q_{k+1}(T_k)\qquad(t\geq T_k).\] At the same time, \(\rho_t^{\mathrm{abs}}(\xi)\geq\rho_0(\xi)>1/2\). Consequently, for \(t\geq T_k\), \[\|\rho_t^{\mathrm{abs}}-\delta_\xi\|_{\ell^1(X)} =2(1-\rho_t^{\mathrm{abs}}(\xi)) \geq2Q_{k+1}(T_k) \geq\frac1K\varepsilon^{\alpha_{k+1}},\] whereas, for \(z\ne\xi\), \[\|\rho_t^{\mathrm{abs}}-\delta_z\|_{\ell^1(X)} =2(1-\rho_t^{\mathrm{abs}}(z)) \geq2\rho_t^{\mathrm{abs}}(\xi)>1.\] This proves the claimed separation, for example with \(c_*\leq1/(2K)\).

When \(k=1\), the lower bound on the central mass holds for every solution at all times. Thus Lemma 4.11 applies with \(m=1\) and \(I=[0,\infty)\). It makes \(p_1\) nonincreasing on the whole half-line, so the empty first shell cannot reappear under any global continuation. The same flux and distance arguments therefore apply to every solution in this case.

We have proved (i)\(\Rightarrow\)(iii) and the contrapositive of (ii)\(\Rightarrow\)(i). The implication (iii)\(\Rightarrow\)(ii) is immediate. All threshold conditions are finite in number and depend only on \(N,d,K,\alpha\). Increasing \(C_*\) to include the extinction constant \(C_F\) completes the proof. ◻

Extension to the exponential interaction

The preceding argument depends on a uniform inward potential gap and on upper bounds for potential differences. Both properties survive for the normalized exponential kernel on any fixed bounded interval of positive \(\beta\). Thus the extension is not restricted to an infinitesimal perturbation of the reduced flow.

Corollary 4.12 (Multiscale classification for the full interaction). Fix \(N\geq3\), \(d\geq2\), \(K>1\), \(\beta_0>0\), and an exponent sequence as in Theorem 4.2, with unequal consecutive gaps. There exist \[\varepsilon_*^{\mathrm{full}} =\varepsilon_*^{\mathrm{full}}(N,d,K,\alpha,\beta_0) \in(0,\varepsilon_*]\] and \(C_*^{\mathrm{full}},c_*^{\mathrm{full}}>0\), depending only on the same parameters, with the following property. For \(0<\beta\leq\beta_0\), consider the full flow \[\tag{4.35} \dot\rho_t(x)=2\sum_{y\in X}a(x,y) \Theta(\rho_t(x),\rho_t(y)) \bigl((k_\beta*\rho_t)(x)-(k_\beta*\rho_t)(y)\bigr), \qquad k_\beta=e^{\beta\sigma}.\] If \(0<\varepsilon<\varepsilon_*^{\mathrm{full}}\) and \(\rho_0\) satisfies \((H_\alpha)_{\xi,K,\varepsilon}\), then the following conditions are equivalent:

  1. \(\Delta_1<\cdots<\Delta_R\);

  2. the support-nonincreasing solution \(\rho^{\beta,\mathrm{abs}}\) converges to \(\delta_\xi\);

  3. every global solution of (4.35) from \(\rho_0\) converges to \(\delta_\xi\).

If these conditions hold, every solution reaches \(\delta_\xi\) and remains there after a time \[T_\beta\leq\frac{C_*^{\mathrm{full}}}{\beta} \varepsilon^{\alpha_1}|\log\varepsilon|.\] If (i) fails and \(k\) is the first decreasing gap, there is a time \[T_{\beta,k}\leq\frac{C_*^{\mathrm{full}}}{\beta} \varepsilon^{\Delta_k}|\log\varepsilon|\] such that, for \(t\geq T_{\beta,k}\), \[\sum_{x\in S_k}\rho_t^{\beta,\mathrm{abs}}(x)=0,\] \[\sum_{r_\xi(x)\geq k+1}\rho_t^{\beta,\mathrm{abs}}(x) =\sum_{r_\xi(x)\geq k+1}\rho_{T_{\beta,k}}^{\beta,\mathrm{abs}}(x) \geq c_*^{\mathrm{full}}\varepsilon^{\alpha_{k+1}},\] and \[\inf_{z\in X}\|\rho_t^{\beta,\mathrm{abs}}-\delta_z\|_{\ell^1(X)} \geq c_*^{\mathrm{full}}\varepsilon^{\alpha_{k+1}}.\] For \(k=1\), these conclusions hold for every global solution, with a solution-dependent \(T_{\beta,1}\). All constants and thresholds are uniform for \(\beta\in(0,\beta_0]\).

Proof. Define \[h_\beta:=\frac{e^{\beta\sigma}-1}{\beta}, \qquad U_{\beta,\rho}:=h_\beta*\rho.\] Taylor’s formula gives \[\tag{4.36} \|h_\beta-\sigma\|_{\ell^\infty(X)} \leq\frac{\beta d^2}2e^{\beta d}.\] For uniform estimates over the entire interval \((0,\beta_0]\), use \(g_\beta(s):=(e^{\beta s}-1)/\beta\) and \[\tag{4.37} e^{-\beta_0d}\leq g_\beta'(s)=e^{\beta s}\leq e^{\beta_0d} \qquad(s\in[-d,d],\ 0<\beta\leq\beta_0).\] The mean value theorem and Lemma 4.5 imply \[\tag{4.38} h_\beta(y-\xi)-h_\beta(x-\xi) \geq e^{-\beta_0d}\kappa_N \qquad(y\prec_\xi x).\] For every edge \(x\sim y\) and every \(z\in X\), they also give \[\tag{4.39} |h_\beta(y-z)-h_\beta(x-z)| \leq e^{\beta_0d}|\sigma(y-z)-\sigma(x-z)| \leq2e^{\beta_0d}.\] Put \[\kappa_{\beta_0}:=e^{-\beta_0d}\kappa_N, \qquad L_{\beta_0}:=2e^{\beta_0d}, \qquad q_{\beta_0}:= \frac{\kappa_{\beta_0}}{2(\kappa_{\beta_0}+L_{\beta_0})}.\] Writing \(\rho=(1-q)\delta_\xi+\mu\), where \(q=1-\rho(\xi)\) and \(\mu(X)=q\), yields \[U_{\beta,\rho}(y)-U_{\beta,\rho}(x) \geq(1-q)\kappa_{\beta_0}-qL_{\beta_0} \qquad(y\prec_\xi x).\] Hence \[\tag{4.40} q\leq q_{\beta_0} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad U_{\beta,\rho}(y)-U_{\beta,\rho}(x) \geq\frac{\kappa_{\beta_0}}2.\] Since \(g_\beta(0)=0\), the same derivative bound gives \(\|h_\beta\|_\infty\leq de^{\beta_0d}\) and thus \[\tag{4.41} |U_{\beta,\rho}(x)-U_{\beta,\rho}(y)| \leq2de^{\beta_0d}\qquad(x,y\in X).\]

Consider the normalized equation \tag{4.42} \begin{align*} \partial_\tau\widetilde\rho_\tau(x) ={}&2\sum_{y\in X}a(x,y) \Theta(\widetilde\rho_\tau(x),\widetilde\rho_\tau(y))\\ &\quad\cdot\bigl(U_{\beta,\widetilde\rho_\tau}(x) -U_{\beta,\widetilde\rho_\tau}(y)\bigr). \end{align*} Its vector field has the continuity, tangency, and relative-interior smoothness properties of Proposition 2.2. In particular, it has global solutions and a unique support-nonincreasing continuation.

We verify the ingredients of the reduced proof with constants uniform in \(\beta\). The inward bound (4.40) gives Lemma 4.6, Lemma 4.7, Lemma 4.8 with \(\kappa_N,q_*\) replaced by \(\kappa_{\beta_0},q_{\beta_0}\). Choose \(\varepsilon\) so that \[C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_1}\leq\frac{q_{\beta_0}}2\] and the initial central mass exceeds \(1/2\). The radial orientation, the tail upper bounds, and this central lower bound then persist for all normalized times. The potential bound (4.41) and Lemma 4.3 give the loss estimate with a uniform constant \(C_L^{\mathrm{full}}\). Likewise, the proof of Lemma 4.10 uses only the inward gap, the tail bounds, and the adjacent lower bound; it gives uniform constants \(c_E^{\mathrm{full}},C_E^{\mathrm{full}}\).

For a shell with an outer tail, let \(n_m:=|S_m|\) and let \(E_m\) be the number of edges joining \(S_m\) to \(S_{m+1}\). Its outward-to-inward flux comparison is controlled by \[\mathcal J_m\geq\frac{\kappa_{\beta_0}}{2d} \Theta\left(\frac{p_m}{n_m},c_K\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}\right),\] \[\mathcal J_{m+1}\leq\frac{L_{\beta_0}E_m}{d} \Theta\left(p_m,C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m+1}}\right).\] Divide both arguments of the logarithmic means by \(\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}\). Since \(p_m/\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}} \leq C_H\varepsilon^{\Delta_m}\), Lemma 4.4 shows that \(\mathcal J_{m+1}\leq\mathcal J_m/2\) for sufficiently small \(\varepsilon\), uniformly in \(\beta\). The proof of Lemma 4.11 therefore gives uniform constants \(c_F^{\mathrm{full}},C_F^{\mathrm{full}}\), including the estimate for mass transferred from the outer tail.

For increasing gaps, impose the uniform version of (4.25): \[C_L^{\mathrm{full}}C_E^{\mathrm{full}} \sum_{m=i+1}^R\varepsilon^{\alpha_{i-1}+\Delta_m} \leq\frac1{4K}\varepsilon^{\alpha_i} \qquad(1\leq i<R).\] The descending induction in Theorem 4.2 then gives extinction by normalized time \[\tau_\beta\leq C_*^{\mathrm{full}} \varepsilon^{\alpha_1}|\log\varepsilon|\] for every solution. For a first decreasing gap at \(k\), impose instead \[C_L^{\mathrm{full}}C_F^{\mathrm{full}} \varepsilon^{\alpha_{i-1}+\Delta_k} \leq\frac1{4K}\varepsilon^{\alpha_i} \qquad(1\leq i<k),\] \[(C_F^{\mathrm{full}})^2 \varepsilon^{\alpha_k+\Delta_k} \leq\frac1{2K}\varepsilon^{\alpha_{k+1}}.\] The strict exponent inequalities are unchanged. The same stopped argument produces an empty shell at normalized time \[\tau_{\beta,k}\leq C_*^{\mathrm{full}} \varepsilon^{\Delta_k}|\log\varepsilon|,\] with at least \(\varepsilon^{\alpha_{k+1}}/(2K)\) mass beyond it. For the support-nonincreasing continuation this mass is conserved after the shell empties, and the distance estimates follow as before. For \(k=1\), the persistent central lower bound makes the conclusion valid for every global solution. A finite number of uniform smallness conditions determines \(\varepsilon_*^{\mathrm{full}}\), which can be decreased to be at most \(\varepsilon_*\).

Finally, \[k_\beta*\rho=1+\beta U_{\beta,\rho}.\] Thus \(\rho\) solves the full equation if and only if \(\widetilde\rho_\tau:=\rho_{\tau/\beta}\) solves the normalized one. This reparametrization preserves the support-nonincreasing property and all mass bounds. It changes the extinction times to \(T_\beta=\tau_\beta/\beta\) and \(T_{\beta,k}=\tau_{\beta,k}/\beta\), proving the statement. ◻

5. Non-genericity of convergence to a Dirac mass

The multiscale criterion identifies initial densities that concentrate, but proximity to a Dirac mass is not sufficient for concentration. We now construct open sets of strictly positive densities on which the polynomial condition in Theorem 3.4 fails for every target. The same construction also excludes convergence of each individual continuation, a stronger conclusion than exclusion from the universal basin. The argument uses two affine mass inequalities and works simultaneously for \(h=\sigma\) and every \(h=k_\beta\), \(\beta>0\).

Throughout this section, assume \(N\geq3\) and \(d\geq2\), and fix \(\xi\in X\). Using the shells introduced in the preceding section, write \[\mathcal R_\xi:=\bigcup_{m=2}^R S_m^\xi,\] and define \tag{5.1} \begin{align*} P_\xi(\rho)&:=\sum_{x\in S_1^\xi}\rho(x), &Q_{2,\xi}(\rho)&:=\sum_{x\in\mathcal R_\xi}\rho(x),\\ q_\xi(\rho)&=P_\xi(\rho)+Q_{2,\xi}(\rho), &B_\xi(\rho)&:=Q_{2,\xi}(\rho)-P_\xi(\rho). \end{align*} Thus \(B_\xi\) compares the exterior mass with the mass available in the first shell. Both \(S_1^\xi\) and \(\mathcal R_\xi\) are nonempty under the present assumptions. To distinguish the first-shell mass \(P_\xi\) from a polynomial certificate, the latter will be denoted by \(\Pi\).

Set \[\tag{5.2} \begin{gathered} c_N:=1-\cos(2\pi/N),\qquad C_N:=\frac{2}{c_N},\qquad D:=2d-1,\\ r_*:=\min\left\{\frac14,\frac{1}{2(1+C_N)}, \frac{1}{128D^2C_N^2}\right\}. \end{gathered}\] These constants depend only on \(N\) and \(d\).

Lemma 5.1 (Two affine barriers near a Dirac mass). For \(h=\sigma\) or \(h=k_\beta\) with arbitrary \(\beta>0\), and every \(\rho\in\mathcal P(X)\) with \(q_\xi(\rho)\leq r_*\), \[\tag{5.3} \mathcal L_{F^h}q_\xi(\rho)\leq0, \qquad \mathcal L_{F^h}B_\xi(\rho)\geq0.\] The inequalities hold on the closed simplex, with the same \(r_*\) for all the kernels under consideration.

Proof deferred to Appendix 6.

Theorem 5.2 (An open obstruction to Dirac convergence). Choose \[\tag{5.4} 0<b<r<r_*.\] Then \[\tag{5.5} \mathcal U_\xi(r,b):= \{\rho\in\mathcal P_*(X):q_\xi(\rho)<r,\ B_\xi(\rho)>b\}\] is nonempty and open in \(\mathcal P_*(X)\). Let \[\tag{5.6} \mathcal C_\xi(r,b):= \{\rho\in\mathcal P(X):q_\xi(\rho)\leq r,\ B_\xi(\rho)\geq b\}.\] For \(h=\sigma\) and for every \(h=k_\beta\), \(\beta>0\), the following conclusions hold.

  1. For every \(z\in X\), every \(n\) with \(\varepsilon_{h,n}\leq b\), and every real polynomial \(\Pi\), \[\tag{5.7} \left[\Pi-\mathcal L_{F^h}\Pi\geq1\text{ on }K_{h,z,n}\right] \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \min_{\rho\in\mathcal C_\xi(r,b)}\Pi(\rho)\geq1.\] In particular, each initial datum in \(\mathcal U_\xi(r,b)\) violates the certificate condition in Theorem 3.4 for every target. The indices may be chosen uniformly in \(h\) and \(z\) by taking \[\tag{5.8} n\geq n_0(b):= \max\left\{1,\left\lceil\log_2\frac{1}{4b}\right\rceil\right\}.\]

  2. Every global solution starting in \(\mathcal C_\xi(r,b)\) remains in this polytope and satisfies \[\tag{5.9} \inf_{z\in X}\|\rho_t-\delta_z\|_{\ell^1(X)}\geq2b \qquad(t\geq0).\] Consequently, no global solution starting in \(\mathcal U_\xi(r,b)\) converges to a Dirac mass.

The open set, the polytope, and the separation bound are independent of \(\beta>0\).

Proof. The strict affine inequalities in (5.5) define a relatively open set. To prove nonemptiness, set \(p=(r-b)/8\) and \(s=b+3p\), and distribute mass \(p\) uniformly on \(S_1^\xi\), mass \(s\) uniformly on \(\mathcal R_\xi\), and mass \(1-p-s\) at \(\xi\). This density is strictly positive and satisfies \[q_\xi=p+s=\frac{r+b}{2}<r, \qquad B_\xi=s-p=b+2p>b.\] Hence \(\mathcal U_\xi(r,b)\subset\mathcal C_\xi(r,b)\) is nonempty, and \(\mathcal C_\xi(r,b)\) is a nonempty compact polytope.

Failure of the certificates. If \(\rho\in\mathcal C_\xi(r,b)\), then \[1-\rho(\xi)=B_\xi(\rho)+2P_\xi(\rho)\geq b.\] For \(z\ne\xi\), \[1-\rho(z)\geq\rho(\xi)\geq1-r>b,\] because \(b<r<r_*\leq1/4\). Therefore \[\tag{5.10} \mathcal C_\xi(r,b)\subset\bigcap_{z\in X}K_{h,z,n} \qquad\text{whenever }\varepsilon_{h,n}\leq b.\] Suppose \(\Pi-\mathcal L_{F^h}\Pi\geq1\) on \(K_{h,z,n}\), and let \(\rho_*\) minimize \(\Pi\) on \(\mathcal C_\xi(r,b)\). Put \(v=F^h(\rho_*)\). We have \[\sum_xv(x)=0, \qquad \rho_*(x)=0\ \Longrightarrow\ v(x)=0.\] Thus \(\rho_*+tv\) belongs to the simplex for all sufficiently small \(t\geq0\). Since both additional constraints are affine, Lemma 5.1 also gives \[q_\xi(\rho_*+tv)\leq q_\xi(\rho_*)\leq r, \qquad B_\xi(\rho_*+tv)\geq B_\xi(\rho_*)\geq b.\] The segment therefore lies in \(\mathcal C_\xi(r,b)\) near \(t=0\). Minimality of \(\Pi\) along it implies \[\mathcal L_{F^h}\Pi(\rho_*) =\left.\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}\right|_{t=0^+} \Pi(\rho_*+tv)\geq0.\] Using (5.10), we obtain \[\Pi(\rho_*)= (\Pi-\mathcal L_{F^h}\Pi)(\rho_*)+ \mathcal L_{F^h}\Pi(\rho_*)\geq1.\] This proves (i). In particular, \(\Pi(\rho_0)<0\) is impossible on \(\mathcal U_\xi(r,b)\), so Theorem 3.4 excludes this open set from the universal basin of every target. The uniform index bound follows from \(\varepsilon_{h,n}=q_h2^{-n}\) and \(q_h\leq1/4\).

Exclusion of individual convergent continuations. Failure of universal convergence alone does not rule out a particular convergent solution. To obtain (ii), let \(\rho\) be any global solution starting in \(\mathcal C_\xi(r,b)\). On the maximal initial interval on which \(q_\xi(\rho_t)<r_*\), the first inequality in (5.3) gives \[q_\xi(\rho_t)\leq q_\xi(\rho_0)\leq r<r_*.\] Continuity prevents a finite exit from this interval. The same lemma then applies at every time, and its second inequality gives \(B_\xi(\rho_t)\geq B_\xi(\rho_0)\geq b\). Hence the polytope is invariant for every global continuation. Finally, \[\|\rho_t-\delta_\xi\|_{\ell^1(X)}=2q_\xi(\rho_t)\geq2b,\] and for \(z\ne\xi\), \[\|\rho_t-\delta_z\|_{\ell^1(X)} =2(1-\rho_t(z))\geq2(1-r)>2b.\] This proves the stated separation bound. ◻

Corollary 5.3 (Open obstructions arbitrarily close to a Dirac mass). For every \(\delta>0\), set \[r_\delta:=\min\{r_*/2,\delta/4\},\qquad b_\delta:=r_\delta/2,\qquad \mathcal V_{\xi,\delta}:=\mathcal U_\xi(r_\delta,b_\delta).\] Then \(\mathcal V_{\xi,\delta}\) is a nonempty open subset of \[\{\rho\in\mathcal P_*(X): \|\rho-\delta_\xi\|_{\ell^1(X)}<\delta\}.\] For the reduced flow and every full flow with \(\beta>0\), each global solution starting in \(\mathcal V_{\xi,\delta}\) satisfies \[\inf_{z\in X}\|\rho_t-\delta_z\|_{\ell^1(X)}\geq r_\delta \qquad(t\geq0).\] Every such initial datum fails the certificate condition in Theorem 3.4 for every prescribed Dirac mass.

Proof. The parameters satisfy \(0<b_\delta<r_\delta<r_*\). Apply Theorem 5.2, and observe that \[\|\rho_0-\delta_\xi\|_{\ell^1(X)} =2q_\xi(\rho_0)<2r_\delta\leq\delta/2<\delta.\] The uniform separation is \(2b_\delta=r_\delta\). ◻

For each of these vector fields, initial densities admitting a global continuation that converges to some Dirac mass do not form a dense subset of \(\mathcal P_*(X)\). Consequently, Dirac convergence holds neither on a residual set nor for almost every initial density with respect to Lebesgue measure on the affine simplex. This obstruction persists where all first Fourier modes are nonzero: for every \(\rho\in\mathcal U_\xi(r,b)\), \[|A_j(\rho)-e^{-2\pi i\xi_j/N}| \leq2q_\xi(\rho)<2r_*<1.\] The coexistence of the multiscale concentration sets and these open obstructions is therefore governed by the distribution of mass between shells, even arbitrarily close to a Dirac mass.

Appendix A. Proofs of auxiliary results

Proof of Lemma 2.4

Proof. The identity (2.12) gives \[\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}J(\rho_t)=4\|\nabla U_{\rho_t}\|_{\rho_t}^2\geq0.\] Suppose that \(\rho_t\to\rho_\infty\in\mathcal P_*(X)\). The right-hand side converges by continuity. Its limit is zero, since a positive limit would contradict \(J\leq d\). Every edge has positive mobility at \(\rho_\infty\), so connectedness gives that \(U_{\rho_\infty}\) is constant. Its spatial mean is zero, because \(\sum_x\sigma(x)=0\), hence \(U_{\rho_\infty}=0\) and \(J(\rho_\infty)=0\). This contradicts \(J(\rho_t)\geq J(\rho_0)>0\). ◻

Proof of Proposition 2.5

Proof. Differentiation and (2.2), applied complex-linearly, give \begin{align*} \frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}A_j(\rho_t) &=\sum_{x,y}a(x,y)\Theta(\rho_t(x),\rho_t(y)) \bigl(U_{\rho_t}(y)-U_{\rho_t}(x)\bigr) \bigl(\chi_j(y)-\chi_j(x)\bigr)\notag\\\tag{A.1} &=\frac{\omega-1}{d}\sum_x\Theta(\rho_t(x),\rho_t(x+e_j)) \bigl(U_{\rho_t}(x+e_j)-U_{\rho_t}(x)\bigr)\chi_j(x). \end{align*} Only edges in the \(j\)th coordinate direction contribute. The first-mode representation of the potential yields \[U_{\rho_t}(x+e_j)-U_{\rho_t}(x) =\frac12\left((\overline\omega-1)A_j(\rho_t)\overline{\chi_j(x)} +(\omega-1)\overline{A_j(\rho_t)}\chi_j(x)\right).\] Substitution in (A.1) gives \[\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}A_j(\rho_t) =\frac1{2d}\left(|\omega-1|^2M_{0,j}(\rho_t)A_j(\rho_t) +(\omega-1)^2M_{2,j}(\rho_t)\overline{A_j(\rho_t)}\right).\] Consequently, \[\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}|A_j(\rho_t)|^2 =\frac1d\left(|\omega-1|^2M_{0,j}(\rho_t)|A_j(\rho_t)|^2 +\operatorname{Re}\left((\omega-1)^2M_{2,j}(\rho_t) \overline{A_j(\rho_t)}^{2}\right)\right).\] The triangle inequality gives \(|M_{2,j}|\leq M_{0,j}\) and therefore \[\begin{aligned} 0&\leq\frac{|\omega-1|^2}{d} \bigl(M_{0,j}(\rho_t)-|M_{2,j}(\rho_t)|\bigr)|A_j(\rho_t)|^2\\ &\leq\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}|A_j(\rho_t)|^2 \leq\frac{2|\omega-1|^2}{d}M_{0,j}(\rho_t)|A_j(\rho_t)|^2. \end{aligned}\] Finally, \(\Theta(s,t)\leq(s+t)/2\) implies \(M_{0,j}(\rho_t)\leq1\). Grönwall’s inequality proves (2.14), including the invariance of a zero mode. All identities remain valid when coordinates vanish, by continuity of the logarithmic mean. ◻

Proof of Corollary 2.6

Proof. The lower estimate in (2.14), together with \(|A_j(\rho_t)|\leq1\) and \(A_j(\rho_0)\ne0\), implies \[\int_0^\infty\bigl(M_{0,j}(\rho_t)-|M_{2,j}(\rho_t)|\bigr)\,\mathrm dt<\infty.\] Since \(\rho_t\to\rho_\infty\), the continuous nonnegative integrand has limit zero. Thus \(M_{0,j}(\rho_\infty)=|M_{2,j}(\rho_\infty)|\). If \(M_{0,j}(\rho_\infty)=0\), no edge in direction \(j\) has two positive endpoints and the conclusion is vacuous. Otherwise, equality in the triangle inequality for \(M_{2,j}\) forces all \(\chi_j(x)^2\) with \(\Theta(\rho_\infty(x),\rho_\infty(x+e_j))>0\) to coincide. Choosing one such edge and denoting its \(j\)th coordinate by \(a_j\) gives \(e^{-4\pi i x_j/N}=e^{-4\pi i a_j/N}\) on every such edge, which is the claimed congruence. ◻

Proof of Lemma 3.1

Proof of Lemma 3.1. Enlarging \(B\) slightly inside the neighborhood on which \(u\) is \(C^1\), if necessary, we may assume that \(B\) has nonempty interior. An affine change of variables then reduces the problem to \([0,1]^m\). For \(n\ge1\), the tensor-product Bernstein polynomial is \[B_nu(x)=\sum_{k\in\{0,\ldots,n\}^m} u(k/n)\prod_{i=1}^m\binom n{k_i}x_i^{k_i}(1-x_i)^{n-k_i}.\] The weights are nonnegative and sum to one. If the \(K_i\) are independent binomial random variables with parameters \((n,x_i)\), then \(B_nu(x)=\mathbb E[u(K/n)]\), and \[\mathbb E\|K/n-x\|^2 =\sum_{i=1}^m\frac{x_i(1-x_i)}n\le\frac m{4n}.\] For every \(a>0\), uniform continuity of \(u\) and Markov’s inequality give, with \(\omega_u\) denoting its modulus of continuity, \[|B_nu(x)-u(x)| \le\omega_u(a)+2\|u\|_{\infty,B}\frac m{4na^2}.\] Letting first \(n\to\infty\) and then \(a\downarrow0\) yields uniform convergence.

Differentiation in the \(i\)th coordinate gives exactly \[\begin{aligned} \partial_iB_nu(x) &=\sum_{\substack{0\le k_i\le n-1\\0\le k_j\le n\ (j\ne i)}} n\bigl(u((k+e_i)/n)-u(k/n)\bigr)\\ &\hspace{8mm}\times \binom{n-1}{k_i}x_i^{k_i}(1-x_i)^{n-1-k_i} \prod_{j\ne i}\binom n{k_j}x_j^{k_j}(1-x_j)^{n-k_j}. \end{aligned}\] The finite-difference coefficient satisfies \[n\bigl(u((k+e_i)/n)-u(k/n)\bigr) =\int_0^1\partial_i u(k/n+\theta e_i/n)\mathrm d\theta.\] It therefore differs from \(\partial_i u(k/n)\) by at most \(\omega_{\partial_i u}(1/n)\), uniformly in \(k\). The new weights still sum to one. They correspond to \(K_i\sim\operatorname{Bin}(n-1,x_i)\) and \(K_j\sim\operatorname{Bin}(n,x_j)\) for \(j\ne i\). This time, \[\mathbb E\|K/n-x\|^2\le \frac m{4n}+\frac1{n^2}.\] The same uniform-continuity argument, applied to \(\partial_i u\), proves uniform convergence of the derivatives. The initial affine change of variables preserves \(C^1\) convergence, proving (3.2).

Finally, a fixed polynomial has only finitely many coefficients. On a compact box, its values and derivatives depend continuously on those coefficients. Approximating them by rational numbers therefore gives any prescribed strictly positive \(C^1\) error tolerance. ◻

Proof of Proposition 3.2

Proof of Proposition 3.2. 1. A trajectory induces a measure. If (i) holds, set \[\mu=\int_0^{+\infty}e^{-t}\delta_{z(t)}dt.\] This is a probability measure supported on \(K\). For every polynomial \(p\), \[\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}\bigl(e^{-t}p(z(t))\bigr) =e^{-t}\bigl(\mathcal L_F p(z(t))-p(z(t))\bigr).\] Since \(p\) is bounded on \(K\), we have \(e^{-T}p(z(T))\to0\). Integrating over \([0,T]\) and passing to the limit gives (3.3).

2. A bounded extension and the distributional formulation. Assume (ii). Let \(\pi_S:\mathbb{R}^m\to S\) be the Euclidean projection onto the closed convex set \(S\), and define \[\widetilde F(x)=F(\pi_S(x)).\] The metric projection is \(1\)-Lipschitz. Since \(F\) is uniformly continuous on \(S\), the vector field \(\widetilde F\) is uniformly continuous on \(\mathbb{R}^m\), bounded by \(B_F=\sup_S \| F\|\), and agrees with \(F\) on \(S\).

Regard \(\mu\) as a measure on \(\mathbb{R}^m\). Given \(\varphi\in C_c^\infty(\mathbb{R}^m)\), choose a box containing \(S\). Lemma 3.1 allows us to approximate \(\varphi\) and its gradient on this box by polynomials. Since \(\mu\) is a probability measure, \(F\) is bounded on \(K\), and \(r\in S\), we may pass to the limit in (3.3). We obtain \[\tag{A.2} \int\bigl(\varphi-\widetilde F\cdot\nabla\varphi\bigr)\mathrm d\mu =\varphi(r)\qquad(\varphi\in C_c^\infty(\mathbb{R}^m)).\] In distributional notation, this reads \[\tag{A.3} \mu+\operatorname{div}(\widetilde F\mu)=\delta_r.\] The vector-valued measure \(\widetilde F\mu\) is finite and supported on \(K\).

3. Gaussian regularization. For \(\varepsilon>0\), let \[g_\varepsilon(x)=(2\pi\varepsilon^2)^{-m/2} e^{-\|x\|^2/(2\varepsilon^2)}.\] Set \[\tag{A.4} m_\varepsilon=\mu*g_\varepsilon,\qquad j_\varepsilon=(\widetilde F\mu)*g_\varepsilon,\qquad b_\varepsilon=\frac{j_\varepsilon}{m_\varepsilon},\qquad s_\varepsilon(x)=g_\varepsilon(x-r).\] Since the Gaussian is strictly positive and \(\mu\) has total mass one, \(m_\varepsilon(x)>0\) for every \(x\). The functions \(m_\varepsilon\), \(j_\varepsilon\), and \(b_\varepsilon\) are smooth. Moreover, \[\tag{A.5} \|b_\varepsilon(x)\| \le\frac{\int\|\widetilde F(y)\|g_\varepsilon(x-y)d\mu(y)} {m_\varepsilon(x)}\le B_F.\] Convolving (A.3) gives \[\tag{A.6} m_\varepsilon+\operatorname{div}(b_\varepsilon m_\varepsilon)=s_\varepsilon.\] Here both \(m_\varepsilon(x)\mathrm dx\) and \(s_\varepsilon(x)\mathrm dx\) are probability measures.

4. Exact representation for the regularized vector field. The vector field \(b_\varepsilon\) is smooth and bounded. Its flow \(\Phi_t^\varepsilon\) is therefore defined for every \(t\in\mathbb{R}\): by (A.5), a solution cannot escape to infinity in finite time, and local regularity allows continuation. We will prove the measure identity \[\tag{A.7} m_\varepsilon(x)\mathrm dx =\int_0^{+\infty}e^{-t} (\Phi_t^\varepsilon)_\#(s_\varepsilon(x)\mathrm dx)\mathrm dt.\]

For \(\varphi\in C_c^\infty(\mathbb{R}^m)\) and \(T>0\), define \[u_T(x)=\int_0^Te^{-t}\varphi(\Phi_t^\varepsilon(x))\mathrm dt.\] This function is smooth and compactly supported. Indeed, if \(\operatorname{supp}\varphi\subset\overline B(0,R_0)\) and \(\| x\|>R_0+B_FT\), then \(\|\Phi_t^\varepsilon(x)\|\ge\| x\|-B_Ft>R_0\) for \(0\le t\le T\), and \(u_T(x)=0\). The group property of the autonomous flow gives \[b_\varepsilon(x)\cdot\nabla_x \varphi(\Phi_t^\varepsilon(x)) =\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}\varphi(\Phi_t^\varepsilon(x)).\] Indeed, differentiate \(\Phi_t^\varepsilon(\Phi_s^\varepsilon(x))= \Phi_{t+s}^\varepsilon(x)\) at \(s=0\). Integration by parts in time yields \[u_T-b_\varepsilon\cdot\nabla u_T =\varphi-e^{-T}\varphi\circ\Phi_T^\varepsilon.\] Testing (A.6) against \(u_T\) gives \begin{align*} \tag{A.8} \int\varphi(x)m_\varepsilon(x)\mathrm dx &=\int_0^Te^{-t}\int \varphi(\Phi_t^\varepsilon(x))s_\varepsilon(x)dx dt \\\tag{A.9} &\quad+e^{-T}\int \varphi(\Phi_T^\varepsilon(x))m_\varepsilon(x)d x. \end{align*} The absolute value of the last term is bounded by \(e^{-T}\|\varphi\|_\infty\). Letting \(T\to+\infty\) proves (A.7), first for test functions. Since both sides are finite nonnegative measures, the identity then holds for all nonnegative Borel functions and for bounded Borel functions. Only the regularized vector field is required to have a unique flow.

5. The equation residual tends to zero in mean. We have \begin{align*} \tag{A.10} &\int\|{b_\varepsilon(x)-\widetilde F(x)}\| m_\varepsilon(x)\mathrm dx\\ &\quad\le\iint\|\widetilde F(y)-\widetilde F(x)\| g_\varepsilon(x-y)d x d\mu(y) \longrightarrow0.\notag \end{align*} To justify the limit, bound the difference by a bounded modulus of continuity \(\omega(\|x-y\|)\) for \(\widetilde F\). After the change of variables \(x-y=\varepsilon u\), the bound becomes \(\int\omega(\varepsilon\| u\|)g_1(u)d u\), which tends to zero by dominated convergence.

Also define \(d_K(x)=\min\{1,\operatorname{dist}(x,K)\}\). Since \(\mu\) is supported on \(K\), \[\tag{A.11} \int d_K(x)m_\varepsilon(x)\mathrm dx \le\iint\min\{1,\|x-y\|\}\,g_\varepsilon(x-y)d xd\mu(y) \longrightarrow0.\] Let the sum of the two errors be \[D_\varepsilon=\int \bigl(\|b_\varepsilon-\widetilde F\|+d_K\bigr) m_\varepsilon\mathrm dx\longrightarrow0.\] By (A.7), for every integer \(j\ge1\), \begin{align*} \tag{A.12} &\int s_\varepsilon(y)\int_0^j \bigl(\|b_\varepsilon-\widetilde F\|+d_K\bigr) (\Phi_t^\varepsilon(y))\mathrm dt\mathrm dy \le e^jD_\varepsilon. \end{align*} Indeed, \(1\le e^je^{-t}\) on \([0,j]\), and the integrands are nonnegative. Finally, \[\int\|y-r\|s_\varepsilon(y)d y =\varepsilon\int\| u\|\,g_1(u)d u\longrightarrow0.\]

6. Selecting trajectories and passing to the limit. For each \(j\), choose \(0<\varepsilon_j<1/j\) sufficiently small that \[\int\|y-r\|s_{\varepsilon_j}(y)d y +e^jD_{\varepsilon_j}\le\frac1j.\] The mean of the nonnegative quantity \[Z_j(y)=\|y-r\|+\int_0^j \bigl(\|b_{\varepsilon_j}-\widetilde F\|+d_K\bigr) (\Phi_t^{\varepsilon_j}(y))d t\] with respect to the probability measure \(s_{\varepsilon_j}(y)\mathrm dy\) is at most \(1/j\). Hence there exists \(y_j\) with \(Z_j(y_j)\le2/j\). Define \[z_j(t)=\Phi_t^{\varepsilon_j}(y_j)\qquad(t\ge0).\] Then \[\tag{A.13} \|y_j-r\|\le\frac2j,\qquad \int_0^j\|\dot z_j(t)-\widetilde F(z_j(t))\|d t\le\frac2j, \qquad \int_0^j d_K(z_j(t))\mathrm dt\le\frac2j.\] The velocities are bounded by \(B_F\). On every interval \([0,L]\), the curves are therefore uniformly Lipschitz and uniformly bounded. Applying the Arzelà–Ascoli theorem successively on \([0,1]\), \([0,2],\ldots\), and then taking a diagonal subsequence, yields a subsequence converging uniformly on every bounded interval to a curve \(z\). We have \(z(0)=r\).

For each \(L\), continuity of \(d_K\) and the last inequality in (A.13) imply \[\int_0^L d_K(z(t))\mathrm dt=0.\] The integrand is continuous and nonnegative, so \(d_K(z(t))=0\) for every \(t\in[0,L]\). Since \(K\) is closed, \(z(t)\in K\) for every \(t\ge0\).

On the other hand, \[z_j(t)=y_j+\int_0^t\widetilde F(z_j(s))\mathrm ds+e_j(t),\qquad \sup_{0\le t\le L}\|e_j(t)\|\le\frac2j \quad(j\ge L).\] Uniform continuity of \(\widetilde F\) and locally uniform convergence allow us to pass to the limit: \[z(t)=r+\int_0^t\widetilde F(z(s))\mathrm ds =r+\int_0^tF(z(s))\mathrm ds.\] The right-hand side is \(C^1\), since \(F\circ z\) is continuous. Thus \(z\) satisfies (i).

Finally, (3.3) is linear in \(p\), and every polynomial is a finite linear combination of monomials. Testing monomials therefore suffices. ◻

Proof of Lemma 4.3

Proof. For \(0<s<a\), the definition of the logarithmic mean gives \[\Theta(s,a)=\frac{a-s}{\log(a/s)}.\] If \(s\leq a/2\) and \(a\leq1\), then \(a-s\geq a/2\) and \(\log(a/s)\leq|\log s|\), proving (4.5).

For the upper estimate, recall that \(\Theta(s,t)\leq\max\{s,t\}\). This immediately gives (4.7). Suppose \(b<a\) and \(0<s\leq A\varepsilon^a\), \(0<t\leq A\varepsilon^b\). If \(s\geq t\), then \[\Theta(s,t)\leq A\varepsilon^a \leq C\frac{\varepsilon^b}{|\log\varepsilon|},\] because \(\varepsilon^{a-b}|\log\varepsilon|\to0\). If \(s<t\) but \(t\leq A\varepsilon^b/|\log\varepsilon|\), the same conclusion follows from \(\Theta(s,t)\leq t\). In the remaining case, \[\frac ts\geq\frac{\varepsilon^{b-a}}{|\log\varepsilon|},\] so, for sufficiently small \(\varepsilon\), \[\log(t/s)\geq(a-b)|\log\varepsilon| -\log|\log\varepsilon| \geq\frac{a-b}2|\log\varepsilon|.\] Therefore, \[\Theta(s,t)=\frac{t-s}{\log(t/s)} \leq\frac{t}{\log(t/s)} \leq C\frac{\varepsilon^b}{|\log\varepsilon|}.\] The cases with a zero argument follow from the boundary extension of \(\Theta\).

Finally, the representation \[\Theta(s,t)=\int_0^1s^\theta t^{1-\theta}\,\mathrm d\theta \qquad(s,t>0)\] proves monotonicity in each variable. Continuity extends this property to the closed quadrant. ◻

Proof of Lemma 4.4

Proof. For sufficiently small \(p>0\), one has \(p/n\leq A/2\), and hence \[\tag{A.14} \frac1{\Theta(p/n,A)} =\frac{\log(nA/p)}{A-p/n} \leq\frac2A\log(nA/p) \leq C_{A,n}(1+|\log p|).\] It remains to prove \[\tag{A.15} (1+|\log p|)\Theta(p,r)\longrightarrow0 \qquad\text{as }(p,r)\longrightarrow(0,0),\quad p>0.\] The case \(r=0\) is immediate. Otherwise, write \(p=e^{-u}\) and \(r=e^{-v}\), with \(u,v\to\infty\). If \(u=v\), the assertion follows from \(u e^{-u}\to0\). For \(u\ne v\), \[\Theta(p,r)=\frac{|e^{-u}-e^{-v}|}{|u-v|}.\] We estimate \(u\Theta(p,r)\) in four ranges. If \(|u-v|\leq1\), \[u\Theta(p,r)\leq u e^{-\min\{u,v\}}\longrightarrow0.\] If \(v\geq u+1\), then \(u\Theta(p,r)\leq u e^{-u}\to0\). If \(u\geq v+1\) and \(u\geq2v\), then \[u\Theta(p,r)\leq\frac{u}{u-v}e^{-v} \leq2e^{-v}\longrightarrow0.\] In the last range, \(v+1\leq u<2v\), and \[u\Theta(p,r)\leq\frac{u}{u-v}e^{-v} \leq2v e^{-v}\longrightarrow0.\] Since \(\Theta(p,r)\leq\max\{p,r\}\to0\), these estimates prove (A.15). Combining it with (A.14) yields the joint limit. Its uniform formulation (4.9) follows directly from the definition of that limit. ◻

Proof of Lemma 4.5

Proof. An inward edge changes a single coordinate, say \(j\), whose circular distance from \(\xi_j\) decreases from \(q\in\{1,\ldots,\lfloor N/2\rfloor\}\) to \(q-1\). All other terms of \(V_\xi\) cancel, leaving \[V_\xi(y)-V_\xi(x) =\cos\left(\frac{2\pi(q-1)}N\right) -\cos\left(\frac{2\pi q}N\right).\] The function \(q\mapsto\cos(2\pi q/N)\) is strictly decreasing on \([0,\lfloor N/2\rfloor]\). Each difference in the finite minimum defining \(\kappa_N\) is therefore positive, which proves the claim. ◻

Proof of Lemma 4.6

Proof. Write \(\rho=(1-q)\delta_\xi+\mu\), where \(q=1-\rho(\xi)\), \(\mu\geq0\), and \(\mu(X)=q\). On an inward edge, \[\begin{aligned} U_\rho(y)-U_\rho(x) ={}&(1-q)(V_\xi(y)-V_\xi(x))\\ &+\sum_{z\ne\xi}\rho(z) (\sigma(y-z)-\sigma(x-z)). \end{aligned}\] Only one coordinate changes along an edge, so \(|\sigma(y-z)-\sigma(x-z)|\leq2\). By Lemma 4.5, \[U_\rho(y)-U_\rho(x) \geq(1-q)\kappa_N-2q =\kappa_N-q(\kappa_N+2).\] Thus one may choose \[q_*:=\frac{\kappa_N}{2(\kappa_N+2)}.\] For \(q\leq q_*\), the last lower bound is at least \(\kappa_N/2\). ◻

Proof of Lemma 4.7

Proof. Fix \(m\) and sum (2.8), with \(h=\sigma\), over \(\{r_\xi\geq m\}\). Symmetry of \(a\) and \(\Theta\) cancels all edges with both endpoints in the tail. Each remaining edge joins \(S_m\) to \(S_{m-1}\), and hence \[\dot Q_m(t)=2\sum_{\substack{x\in S_m,\ y\in S_{m-1}\\x\sim y}} a(x,y)\Theta(\rho_t(x),\rho_t(y)) (U_{\rho_t}(x)-U_{\rho_t}(y)).\] The orientation estimate and \(a(x,y)=1/(2d)\) give (4.12). Thus \(Q_m\) is nonincreasing on \(I\).

If \(0\in I\), the initial shell bounds imply \[\begin{aligned} Q_m(0) &\leq K\sum_{j=m}^R|S_j|\varepsilon^{\alpha_j}\\ &\leq K|X|\varepsilon^{\alpha_m} =C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}, \end{aligned}\] because \(0<\varepsilon<1\) and \(\alpha_j\geq\alpha_m\) for \(j\geq m\). This proves (4.13); the pointwise estimate follows from \(0\leq\rho_t(x)\leq Q_m(t)\) for \(x\in S_m\).

Finally, if \(Q_m(s)=0\), nonnegativity and monotonicity give \(0\leq Q_m(t)\leq Q_m(s)=0\) for \(s\leq t\leq u\). Persistence thus follows from the scalar differential inequality itself, without a uniqueness assertion at the boundary. ◻

Proof of Lemma 4.8

Proof. Let \(q(t):=Q_1(t)=1-\rho_t(\xi)\). Initially, \(q(0)\leq C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_1}<q_*\). If \(q\) reached \(q_*\), let \(T^\sharp\) be the first such time. On \([0,T^\sharp]\), Lemma 4.7 gives \(\dot q\leq0\) almost everywhere. Hence \(q(T^\sharp)\leq q(0)<q_*\), a contradiction. The region of uniform orientation is therefore preserved for all times. ◻

Proof of Lemma 4.9

Proof. Every edge incident to \(\xi\) is inward toward \(\xi\). Its contribution to the central derivative is nonnegative, giving \(\dot\rho_t(\xi)\geq0\).

Fix \(z\in S_i\), \(i\geq1\). When \(\rho_t(z)=0\), all its incident mobilities vanish and the required inequality is immediate. At a positive coordinate, edges to \(S_{i+1}\) contribute nonnegative terms to \(\dot\rho_t(z)\) by radial orientation. Only edges to \(S_{i-1}\) or to \(S_i\) can contribute to its negative part. Since \(|U_\rho(x)-U_\rho(y)|\leq2d\), \[(\dot\rho_t(z))_- \leq C\sum_{\substack{w\sim z\\r_\xi(w)\leq i}} \Theta(\rho_t(z),\rho_t(w)).\] The tail bound gives \(\rho_t(z)\leq C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_i}\). For \(w\in S_i\), monotonicity of the logarithmic mean yields \[\Theta(\rho_t(z),\rho_t(w)) \leq C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_i} \leq C\frac{\varepsilon^{\alpha_{i-1}}}{|\log\varepsilon|},\] for sufficiently small \(\varepsilon\), because \(\alpha_i>\alpha_{i-1}\). For \(w\in S_{i-1}\) and \(i\geq2\), apply (4.6) with exponents \(\alpha_i>\alpha_{i-1}\) and the corresponding tail bounds. This gives the same upper estimate. When \(i=1\), the inward neighbour is \(\xi\), whose mass is at most \(1\); use (4.6) with \(b=\alpha_0=0\).

There are at most \(2d\) incident edges. Summing the estimates proves (4.17), with constants independent of the solution. ◻

Proof of Lemma 4.10

Proof. Since \(Q_{m+1}=0\) on \(I\), every mobility from \(S_m\) to an outer shell vanishes. Summing the coordinate equation over \(S_m\) also cancels internal edges. By the inward orientation, \[\tag{A.16} \dot q_m(t)\leq-\frac{\kappa_N}{2d} \sum_{\substack{x\in S_m,\ y\in S_{m-1}\\x\sim y}} \Theta(\rho_t(x),\rho_t(y)).\] Assume \(q_m(t)>0\), and choose \(x_t\in S_m\) with \(\rho_t(x_t)\geq q_m(t)/|S_m|\). It has an inward neighbour \(y_t\in S_{m-1}\), for which \(\rho_t(y_t)\geq c_K\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}\). Moreover, \(q_m(t)\leq C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}\). Because \(\alpha_m>\alpha_{m-1}\), decreasing \(\varepsilon_E\) ensures \[\frac{q_m(t)}{|S_m|} \leq\frac12c_K\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}.\] Monotonicity of \(\Theta\) and (4.5) then give \[\begin{aligned} \Theta(\rho_t(x_t),\rho_t(y_t)) &\geq\Theta\left(\frac{q_m(t)}{|S_m|}, c_K\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}\right)\\ &\geq c\frac{\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}} {|\log(q_m(t)/|S_m|)|}. \end{aligned}\] For small enough \(\varepsilon_E\), one has \(q_m(t)<\min\{e^{-2},|S_m|^{-2}\}\); therefore \[|\log(q_m(t)/|S_m|)|\leq C|\log q_m(t)|.\] Inserting this single-edge lower bound into (A.16) proves (4.20).

To integrate the decay estimate, define \[\Phi(r):=\int_0^r|\log u|\,\mathrm du =r(1-\log r),\qquad0<r<e^{-1},\qquad\Phi(0):=0.\] The function \(\Phi\) is strictly increasing. On any compact time interval on which \(q_m>0\), the chain rule yields \[\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}\Phi(q_m(t)) =|\log q_m(t)|\dot q_m(t) \leq-c_E\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}.\] Thus, as long as \(q_m\) stays positive on \([s,t]\subset I\), \[\Phi(q_m(t))\leq\Phi(q_m(s)) -c_E\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}(t-s).\] The initial value on this interval satisfies \[\Phi(q_m(s))\leq\Phi(C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}) \leq C\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}|\log\varepsilon|.\] Choose \(C_E\) so that the right-hand side is bounded by \(c_EC_E\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}|\log\varepsilon|\). If \(q_m(s)=0\), take \(T_m=s\). Otherwise, positivity throughout an interval of length \(C_E\varepsilon^{\Delta_m}|\log\varepsilon|\) would imply \(\Phi(q_m)\leq0\) at its right endpoint, which is impossible. Continuity provides a first zero and proves (4.21). ◻

Proof of Lemma 4.11

Proof. Choose \(\varepsilon_F\) so that radial orientation and the upper tail bounds hold for all times. For \(1\leq j\leq R\), let \[\mathcal J_j(t):=\frac1d \sum_{\substack{x\in S_j,\ y\in S_{j-1}\\x\sim y}} \Theta(\rho_t(x),\rho_t(y)) (U_{\rho_t}(y)-U_{\rho_t}(x)).\] These inward fluxes are nonnegative. The boundary-flux identity gives \[\tag{A.17} \dot Q_j=-\mathcal J_j, \qquad\dot p_m=\mathcal J_{m+1}-\mathcal J_m.\] Write \(n_m:=|S_m|\) and denote by \(E_m\) the number of undirected edges joining \(S_m\) to \(S_{m+1}\).

Choose a point of \(S_m\) carrying at least \(p_m/n_m\) mass and one of its inward neighbours. The potential gap and the inner lower bound give \[\tag{A.18} \mathcal J_m(t)\geq\frac{\kappa_N}{2d} \Theta\left(\frac{p_m(t)}{n_m}, c_K\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}\right).\] On the other hand, \(|U_\rho(x)-U_\rho(y)|\leq2\) on an edge, and every mass on \(S_{m+1}\) is at most \(C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m+1}}\). Hence \[\tag{A.19} \mathcal J_{m+1}(t)\leq\frac{2E_m}{d} \Theta\left(p_m(t),C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m+1}}\right).\]

The comparison of these bounds must be uniform as \(p_m\downarrow0\). For \(p_m(t)>0\), set \[u:=\frac{p_m(t)}{\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}}, \qquad v:=C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m+1}-\alpha_{m-1}}.\] The tail estimate implies \(0<u\leq C_H\varepsilon^{\Delta_m}\), and \(v\to0\) as \(\varepsilon\downarrow0\). By homogeneity of \(\Theta\), \[\frac{\Theta(p_m(t),C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m+1}})} {\Theta(p_m(t)/n_m,c_K\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}})} =\frac{\Theta(u,v)}{\Theta(u/n_m,c_K)}.\] The joint limit in Lemma 4.4 makes this ratio uniformly small over the indicated range of \(u\). There are only finitely many shells, so decreasing \(\varepsilon_F\) gives \[\tag{A.20} \mathcal J_{m+1}(t)\leq\frac12\mathcal J_m(t) \qquad(t\in I).\] At \(p_m=0\), both fluxes vanish because every coordinate of \(S_m\) is zero; thus the inequality remains true there. Together with (A.17), it proves that \(p_m\) is nonincreasing on \(I\). In particular, its zeros persist on the remainder of \(I\) for every continuation.

For \(p_m(t)>0\), the outflow estimate now yields \[\dot p_m(t)\leq-\frac{\kappa_N}{4d} \Theta\left(\frac{p_m(t)}{n_m}, c_K\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}\right).\] For small enough \(\varepsilon_F\), \[\frac{p_m(t)}{n_m}\leq\frac12c_K\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}, \qquad p_m(t)<\min\{e^{-2},n_m^{-2}\}.\] Using (4.5) and \(|\log(p_m/n_m)|\leq C|\log p_m|\) gives (4.23).

For the extinction bound, use \(\Phi(p)=\int_0^p|\log u|\,\mathrm du\). On compact intervals where \(p_m>0\), \[\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}\Phi(p_m(t)) \leq-c_F\varepsilon^{\alpha_{m-1}}.\] Since \(p_m(s)\leq C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}\), one has \(\Phi(p_m(s))\leq C\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}|\log\varepsilon|\). Choose \(C_F\) so that this is at most \(c_FC_F\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}|\log\varepsilon|\). Positivity up to time \(s+C_F\varepsilon^{\Delta_m}|\log\varepsilon|\) would then force \(\Phi(p_m)\leq0\) at that time. This contradiction proves extinction within the stated interval; if \(p_m(s)=0\), there is nothing to prove.

Finally, apply (4.6) to (A.19), using \(p_m\leq C_H\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}\) and \(\alpha_{m+1}>\alpha_m\). It follows that \[0\leq\mathcal J_{m+1}(t) \leq C\frac{\varepsilon^{\alpha_m}}{|\log\varepsilon|}.\] Integrating \(\dot Q_{m+1}=-\mathcal J_{m+1}\) proves (4.24), after increasing \(C_F\) if necessary. ◻

Proof of Lemma 5.1

Proof of Lemma 5.1. The first step is an edge estimate normalized by the central gap. For the kernels under consideration, (3.9) gives \[\lambda_h= \begin{cases} c_N,&h=\sigma,\\ e^{\beta d}(1-e^{-\beta c_N}),&h=k_\beta,\quad\beta>0. \end{cases}\] Then \(\lambda_h>0\) and, for every \(x\sim\xi\), \[\tag{A.21} h(0)-h(x-\xi)=\lambda_h, \qquad |h(u)-h(v)|\leq C_N\lambda_h\quad(u\sim v).\] For \(h=\sigma\), these assertions follow from \(\sigma(0)=d\), \(\sigma(x-\xi)=d-c_N\), and \(|\sigma(u)-\sigma(v)|\leq2\) on an edge. For \(h=k_\beta\), writing \(a=\max\{\sigma(u),\sigma(v)\}\leq d\) and \(\Delta=|\sigma(u)-\sigma(v)|\leq2\), we obtain \[|k_\beta(u)-k_\beta(v)| =e^{\beta a}(1-e^{-\beta\Delta}) \leq e^{\beta d}(1-e^{-2\beta}) \leq\frac{2}{c_N}e^{\beta d}(1-e^{-\beta c_N}).\] The last inequality follows from the concavity of \(t\mapsto1-e^{-\beta t}\), its value zero at \(t=0\), and \(0<c_N\leq2\). This proves (A.21) for every \(\beta>0\).

Write \(q=q_\xi(\rho)\) and \(\rho=(1-q)\delta_\xi+\mu\), where \(\mu\geq0\) and \(\mu(X)=q\). For \(x\in S_1\), the kernel estimates give \[\tag{A.22} U^h_\rho(\xi)-U^h_\rho(x) \geq (1-q)\lambda_h-qC_N\lambda_h \geq\frac{\lambda_h}{2},\] provided \(q\leq r_*\). On every edge \(x\sim y\), they also give \[\tag{A.23} |U^h_\rho(x)-U^h_\rho(y)|\leq C_N\lambda_h.\] This argument only fixes the orientation of edges incident to \(\xi\); the differences between \(S_1\) and \(S_2\) may have either sign.

We shall use the following elementary estimate for the logarithmic mean: \[\tag{A.24} 0\leq s,b\leq r<a \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \Theta(s,b)\leq\sqrt{\frac r a}\,\Theta(s,a).\] Indeed, monotonicity in the second variable gives \(\Theta(s,b)\leq\Theta(s,r)\). This monotonicity follows, for positive arguments, from \(\Theta(u,v)=\int_0^1u^{1-t}v^t\,dt\), and extends to the boundary by continuity. If \(s=0\), (A.24) is immediate. If \(s>0\), use \[\Theta(s,t)=\sqrt{st}\, \Phi\!\left(\frac12\log\frac ts\right),\qquad \Phi(u):=\frac{\sinh u}{u},\qquad\Phi(0):=1.\] The function \(\Phi\) is nondecreasing on \([0,\infty)\): \(u\cosh u-\sinh u\geq0\), since it vanishes at zero and has derivative \(u\sinh u\geq0\). As \(s\leq r<a\), the formula yields \[\frac{\Theta(s,r)}{\Theta(s,a)} =\sqrt{\frac r a}\, \frac{\Phi(\tfrac12\log(r/s))}{\Phi(\tfrac12\log(a/s))} \leq\sqrt{\frac r a}.\] This proves (A.24), including its boundary cases.

Define the outflow from \(S_1\) into \(\xi\) and the signed inflow from \(S_2\) into \(S_1\) by \tag{A.25} \begin{align*} \mathcal O_h(\rho) &:=\frac1d\sum_{x\in S_1} \Theta(\rho(x),\rho(\xi)) \bigl(U^h_\rho(\xi)-U^h_\rho(x)\bigr),\\ \mathcal I_h(\rho) &:=\frac1d\sum_{\substack{x\in S_1,\ y\in S_2\\x\sim y}} \Theta(\rho(x),\rho(y)) \bigl(U^h_\rho(x)-U^h_\rho(y)\bigr). \end{align*} Pairwise cancellation of fluxes within each set gives the exact identities \[\tag{A.26} \mathcal L_{F^h}q_\xi=-\mathcal O_h,\qquad \mathcal L_{F^h}P_\xi=\mathcal I_h-\mathcal O_h,\qquad \mathcal L_{F^h}B_\xi=\mathcal O_h-2\mathcal I_h.\] To check the middle identity, the edges leaving \(S_1\) join it either to \(\xi\) or to \(S_2\); edges with both endpoints in \(S_1\) cancel. This remains true for \(N=3\), when such same-shell edges may occur. The other identities follow by summing over \(\{\xi\}\) and using \(B_\xi=q_\xi-2P_\xi\).

Put \(S(\rho)=\sum_{x\in S_1}\Theta(\rho(x),\rho(\xi))\). By (A.22), \[\mathcal O_h(\rho)\geq\frac{\lambda_h}{2d}S(\rho)\geq0.\] Every \(x\in S_1\) has at most \(D=2d-1\) neighbours in \(S_2\). Moreover, \(\rho(x),\rho(y)\leq r_*\) for \(x,y\ne\xi\), whereas \(\rho(\xi)\geq1-r_*\geq1/2\). Consequently, (A.24) and (A.23) imply \[\begin{aligned} |\mathcal I_h(\rho)| &\leq\frac{DC_N\lambda_h}{d}\sqrt{2r_*}\,S(\rho)\\ &\leq 2DC_N\sqrt{2r_*}\,\mathcal O_h(\rho) \leq\frac14\mathcal O_h(\rho). \end{aligned}\] These estimates remain valid when \(S(\rho)=0\). Together with (A.26), they yield \[\mathcal L_{F^h}q_\xi=-\mathcal O_h\leq0,\qquad \mathcal L_{F^h}B_\xi \geq\mathcal O_h-2|\mathcal I_h| \geq\tfrac12\mathcal O_h\geq0.\] All sums use the continuous boundary extension \(\Theta(0,a)=0\); therefore the argument applies throughout the closed simplex. ◻

Bibliography

[1] S.-N. Chow, W. Huang, Y. Li, and H. Zhou, Fokker–Planck equations for a free energy functional or Markov process on a graph, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 203 (2012), 969–1008. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00205-011-0471-6.

[2] M. Erbar, D. Forkert, J. Maas, and D. Mugnolo, Gradient flow formulation of diffusion equations in the Wasserstein space over a metric graph, Netw. Heterog. Media 17 (2022), no. 5, 687–717. https://doi.org/10.3934/nhm.2022023.

[3] M. Erbar and J. Maas, Gradient flow structures for discrete porous medium equations, Discrete Contin. Dyn. Syst. 34 (2014), no. 4, 1355–1374. https://doi.org/10.3934/dcds.2014.34.1355.

[4] B. Geshkovski, H. Koubbi, Y. Polyanskiy, and P. Rigollet, Dynamic metastability in the self-attention model, preprint, arXiv:2410.06833 (2024). https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.06833.

[5] B. Geshkovski, C. Letrouit, Y. Polyanskiy, and P. Rigollet, A mathematical perspective on Transformers, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. (N.S.) 62 (2025), no. 3, 427–479. https://doi.org/10.1090/bull/1863.

[6] D. Henrion and M. Korda, Convex computation of the region of attraction of polynomial control systems, IEEE Trans. Automat. Control 59 (2014), no. 2, 297–312. https://arxiv.org/abs/1208.1751.

[7] R. Jordan, D. Kinderlehrer, and F. Otto, The variational formulation of the Fokker–Planck equation, SIAM J. Math. Anal. 29 (1998), no. 1, 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1137/S0036141096303359.

[8] J. B. Lasserre, D. Henrion, C. Prieur, and E. Trélat, Nonlinear optimal control via occupation measures and LMI-relaxations, SIAM J. Control Optim. 47 (2008), no. 4, 1643–1666. https://doi.org/10.1137/070685051.

[9] W. Li, Transport information geometry: Riemannian calculus on probability simplex, Inf. Geom. 5 (2022), 161–207. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41884-021-00059-1.

[10] J. Maas, Gradient flows of the entropy for finite Markov chains, J. Funct. Anal. 261 (2011), no. 8, 2250–2292. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfa.2011.06.009.

[11] A. Mielke, A gradient structure for reaction–diffusion systems and for energy-drift-diffusion systems, Nonlinearity 24 (2011), no. 4, 1329–1346. https://doi.org/10.1088/0951-7715/24/4/016.

[12] F. Otto, The geometry of dissipative evolution equations: the porous medium equation, Comm. Partial Differential Equations 26 (2001), no. 1–2, 101–174. https://doi.org/10.1081/PDE-100002243.

Back to top